ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION | VIDEO





COMMENTARY
Free All Political Prisoners Without Delay
By AUNG ZAW Friday, October 14, 2011


COMMENTS (9)
RECOMMEND (417)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT


Earlier this week the Burmese government tried to steal the show when it announced an amnesty for 6,359 prisoners. As the world watched, the prison gates duly opened on Wednesday and by the following evening it was confirmed that exactly 6,359 prisoners had been released.

But only about 200 of those who walked free were prisoners of conscience. The rest were criminals. Despite all the calls from Burma's political opposition, dissidents, ethnic groups and exiles, not to mention the international community at large, around 90 percent of Burma's political prisoners remain behind bars. Some are serving as much as 69-year sentences for the “crime” of expressing their opinions or taking part in public protests.

Aung Zaw is founder and editor of the Irrawaddy magazine. He can be reached at [email protected].

Optimism was high that the government would fulfill its promise after President Thein Sein undertook the bold—perhaps historic—decision to suspend the controversial Myitsone Dam project and went so far as raising the ire of Beijing.

However, his limited response to the emotionally charged issue of political prisoners confirms that each of Thein Sein's steps is set to be slow, cautious and carefully calculated.

Our relief for those who were released is heartfelt, and we should pay tribute to them before we turn our focus back to those who continue to languish in jails across the country.

Popular comedian Zarganar, labor rights activist Su Su Nway and Shan rebel leader Maj-Gen Sao Hso Ten were freed. We applaud them for their sacrifice and will maintain a vigilant watch that their freedom is unrestricted.

But for all Zarganar's quick-witted jokes, his social activities and his high public profile, he does not lead a political organization and is not a threat to the civilian regime’s stability.

Still behind bars are Min Ko Naing and Ko Ko Gyi, two of the organizers of the students' uprising in 1988 and the Saffron Revolution in 2007. There is no news whether these two 88 Generation Student leaders, or other similar activists, will ever be released.

The most disturbing outcome of this week's political theater was that top Burmese officials maintained their lie to the international community that Burma keeps less than 1,000 political dissidents behind bars—and the fact that those who benefit from believing this lie are still happy to buy it.

The indisputable fact is that Burma currently has somewhere around 2,000 political prisoners. The most up-to-date list posted online by the reputable Assistance Association for Political Prisoners stated (before Wednesday's amnesty) that there were 1,998 prisoners of conscience in Burma —222 of whom are Buddhist monks, and 148 of whom are women activists.

Indeed the government admitted as much in August during a meeting between Home Minister Gen. Ko Ko and the UN's special rapporteur for Burma, Tomás Ojea Quintana. According to state-run The New Light of Myanmar, Ko Ko told the UN envoy that the number of political prisoners is not more than 2,000, of whom at least 100 were jailed for drug trafficking, murder, terrorism and insurgency.

That's the problem with telling lies—you have to constantly keep track of what the “truth” is.

Since no independent organization such as the International Committee for the Red Cross has access to Burmese prisons, it is difficult to gauge exact numbers.

Nevertheless, we believe that Burma’s Home Affairs Ministry, its intelligence agencies and secret police have full and precise details of every political prisoner, since they were the ones who conducted the raids, the arbitrary arrests and interrogations of each dissident and each member of a political group. They should also have details of each bogus charge they leveled at these innocent people.

Many of the prisoners of conscience in Burma's rancid jailhouses were framed and charged with trumped-up criminal offenses. Zarganar, Min Ko Naing and Ko Ko Gyi, for example, was jailed for breaking the broadly defined “Electronics Act,” which is frequently used in Burmese courts as a catch-all clause to convict the accused for innocuous crimes such as the illicit use of cell phones, speaking to the media, communicating with exiled groups or unlawful associations, and the illegal possession of foreign currency.

The sentences for these infringements are ludicrously severe—69 years is routinely handed down by Burma's courts.



1  |  2 



COMMENTS (9)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

Ohn Wrote:
23/10/2011
What is it with releasing the criminals? What is the purpose of it? And why is it that nobody seems to mind?


Ohn Wrote:
23/10/2011
Prisoners are like birds and fish hypocrite around the world free on a particular occasion. First catch then release. Again and again. Strangely it works each time as Than Shwe has kindly demonstrated since 1990. This time again all and sundry including usual suspects journals, International Crisis group, Cheltham House, Harn Yawnghwe and even some in NLD thought it was a radical breakthrough. Thein Sein is as much in charge of the situation as the captain of the Titanic after it struck the iceberg. So hold your praises.

Myanmar Patriots Wrote:
20/10/2011
"The President will share Nobel peace prize with U Aung Kyi and DASSK. Please make no mistake to release ALL political prisoners. "

GIVE THAT WORTHLESS CRAP to the dog that bites the hand that feeds. Stuff Nobel Prize. Only pathetic low life would dream of it. NOBEL PRIZE FOR SCIENCE EXCEPTED!

Prozac Wrote:
17/10/2011
The temporary suspension of the Myitsone Dam and this token release of just 10% of the political prisoners are just han-pya, or pretentious maneuvers to deceive the West and ASEAN into relaxing their guard. It is strictly designed to reducing the West's sanctions and the ASEAN to grant Burma the Chairmanship.

Pres. Thein Sein, who is really The inSein Min, the inSein Htaung Min, i.e., the King of Insein Prison, is just playing with the lives of 2,000 hapless prisoners, just like when he committed the ridiculous farce of reducing all their prison sentences by one year ison

KML Wrote:
17/10/2011
President U Thein Sein is currently driving the country at the traffic light of T junction. The right direction is to go for a real reform and savvier of 50 million plus population heading to prosperous, harmonious, inclusive of multiracial, multi-religious and multi cultural meaningful democratic country. If this is the case, The President will share Nobel peace prize with U Aung Kyi and DASSK. Please make no mistake to release ALL political prisoners.

If The President chooses to go other direction, the country will be heading to the dead end of the road falling down to the cliff and the fate is unthinkable.

Mr President, which way are you heading to? But every second is important.

Myint Thein, Dallas Wrote:
17/10/2011
Burma is a resource rich country and does not need American investments since it has secured large investments from China. The Burmese generals want sanctions removed because they want their children educated at American Universities. This will not happen until all political prisoners in Burma are released. This is non-negotiable.

The recently published book "The Burma Campaign" argues that Burma was invaded by Japan to close the "Burma Road" that supplied War-time China.

If the Straits of Malacca is closed by the US Navy due to a show-down in the Taiwan Straits, Chinese troops will invade Burma to secure their oil supplies from the Arakan Coast. And these Chinese troops will never leave, and Burma will become a province of China.

The Burmese generals can't be that stupid, but they are blinded by greed and ignores Burma's national security interests.
Like in Suharto's Indonesia, it will take anti-Chinese riots to topple Naypyidaw and Tayoke Naypyidaw (Mandalay).

Tom Tun Wrote:
16/10/2011
It is just another monkeys circus in town. This time, there is no real monkey, but human being were forced to dress up as monkey and play in the circus. Monkey master is up to next play. There are Min Ko Naing, Ko Ko Gyi and another close to 2000 political prisoners still behind bar. True reconciliation has not progress yet. Talking with ethnic brothers must take place.

Nyi Nyi Wrote:
16/10/2011
3.5% of over 6,000 prisoners released are political prisoners. This is the similar trend as their previous releases under Than Shwe. So, what has changed? The release was all to do with Thein Sein's visit to India and the upcoming discussion about Myanmar in the UN. Only 10% of over 6,000 political prisoners were released and the 90% remains locked up in various prisons across Burma.

Myo Myo Wrote:
15/10/2011
Junta has learned tricks at holding onto power through whatever means: sham election, a few conciliation on media freedom or release of a few p-prisoners. Telling lies becomes part of their lives and policies thinking it may fool activists and civil society. Unfortunately, it fooled among themselves instead, starting from “no p-prisoners in Burma”. Have you ever heard law makers have problem on terminology of “p-prisoner” and “p-of-conscious”? This reminds us of IQ joke by Zarganar.

Junta may again boast of activists can be sent back to tiny cells at any time by so-called “electronic Act”. For this purpose junta’s Nargis Constitution was drafted which sets up the military as a legally autonomous entity, supreme over the govt. Unless the 25% is modified and corrected, reforms louded by TSein and cronies are big jokes.

TSein and cronies openly bullied Burmese society saying aimed at national peace and harmony while attacking minority areas. Are you sure they are reformist?

More Articles in This Section

bullet Sizing Up an Icon

bullet Fighting Corruption Begins at Home

bullet Future of Exiled Burmese Media

bullet How Much Freedom Does Burmese Media Enjoy?

bullet Five Days in Burma

bullet Turning Burma into Next Asian Tiger No Simple Task

bullet With Suu Kyi On Board, Is Burma Finally Moving Toward Real Change?

bullet The ‘Rule of Law’ in Burma

bullet New Doors are Opening in Burma

bullet A Good Beginning to the New Year






Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

Donations

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.