ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION | VIDEO





COMMENTARY
Stemming the Chinese Tide
By YENI Wednesday, July 13, 2011


COMMENTS (7)
RECOMMEND (494)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

Although China has thus far been able to keep the Burmese leaders in their hip pocket while heavily investing in Burma to further both its economic and strategic interests, the Chinese may be on a collision course with Burma’s general population.

The growing animosity of the Burmese people towards Chinese who have come to do business in Burma was highlighted by a clash in Mandalay’s jade market on June 27th.

A group of Chinese buyers allegedly agreed to buy a jade stone from a Burmese gems trader for a price of 4 million kyat (US $5,000), but when they returned to collect the item, the Burmese vendor had already sold it to another customer.

Yeni is news editor of the Irrawaddy magazine. He can be reached at [email protected].

Infuriated, the Chinese buyer allegedly swore at the Burmese dealer and physically assaulted him. A crowd of local Burmese responded by attacking the Chinese traders, who phoned the police.

Although police officers were quickly deployed and brought the situation under control, local Burmese residents who heard about the incident ratcheted up the tension by gathering at the jewelry store and singing the Burmese national anthem. As a result, the police were required to escort the Chinese traders out of the market via a squad car.

No charges were pressed against the Chinese for physical abuse, but the next day they were deported to Yunnan and reportedly banned from reentering Burma (although there were subsequent reports that they were seen at the recent annual gem expo in Naypyidaw).

Although in this instant the lit powder keg was diffused, the rapid and intense anger displayed by the local Burmese community towards the Chinese traders is indicative of the Burmese population’s simmering resentment of the growing Chinese influence over both the social and economic life inside their country.

The Chinese “invasion” of Burma is highly visible in Mandalay, Burma’s second largest city, as well as in Upper Burma, where growing numbers of Chinese migrants have poured in over the last 20 years, secured citizenship cards from corrupt Burmese officials and established successful businesses.

Today, the Chinese are believed to make up 30–40 percent of the 1 million people residing in Mandalay, the capital of Burma’s last kingdom and a hub of traditional Burmese culture and Buddhism.

While the Chinese are largely responsible for the economic revitalization of Mandalay’s downtown area—which has been rebuilt with apartment blocks, hotels and shopping malls—and for returning the city to its role as the trading hub connecting Lower Burma, Upper Burma, China and India, their dominance of the city center has pushed Mandalay’s Burmese residents out to the suburbs.

Ludu Daw Amar, who was Burma’s best-known female journalist and social critic before her death in April 2008, once told The Irrawaddy that Mandalay felt like "an undeclared colony of Yunnan," and the recognition of this by the local Burmese community has fueled the fire of anti-Chinese sentiment in the city. 

But the Chinese, whose business interests in Burma are supported by their national government, are not going away. As a growing powerhouse in the regional and global economy and geopolitical landscape, China has a clear strategy of using Burma to advance its interests in those areas.

China is now Burma's second-largest trading partner and biggest foreign investor. The latest official Chinese statistics reveal that the country’s investment in Burma reached $12.32 billion, primarily in oil, gas and hydroelectric ventures.

Experts have noted that Burma is an important part of China’s effort to revive its “Southwestern Silk Road,” running from Yunnan Province down to Burma, and then westward to Bangladesh, India and the Indian Ocean.

 One of the biggest Chinese projects is construction of pipelines that will annually bring 12 million tons of crude oil from Africa and the Middle East through one pipeline, and 12 billion cubic meters of Burmese gas through another, into China’s Yunnan Province from Burma’s western Arakanese coast. Chinese companies are also involved in an estimated 60 hydropower projects in Burma.

To first grease the wheels for these investments, and then protect them once they were underway, China has supported the Burmese generals with military and economic assistance since the 1988 military coup, while at the same time most Western governments have placed sanctions on the Burmese military and its leaders.



1  |  2 | 3 



COMMENTS (7)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

U Thant II Wrote:
22/07/2011
China is not the only neighbour we have.
The Burmese leadership cannot make changes alone. However, with the help of Malaysians, Thais and Indians, it can open up gradually to the West. We need to balance the Chinese in our economy. They have too much influence. And the reason why the Junta has had so much strength is because the Chinese have held their hands from making the reforms necessary. We, the ordinary people have suffered directly and have been hurt because of Chinese intervention in our domestic affairs.

Moe Aung Wrote:
21/07/2011
To expect Chinese migrant capitalists on a feeding frenzy to respect our social, cultural and natural environment is akin to hoping the tiger will turn vegetarian. If our rulers are not bothered about these things why would outsiders be?

Our generals are more than happy in the role of the native comprador bourgeoisie. Sure they'll continue to pay lip service to patriotism, but their nationalism has buckled under the weight of filthy lucre despite their sinophobia and xenophobia.

We must all unite in our historic struggle to get rid of the military yoke that has transformed into one with nasty spikes thanks to their foreign partners once and for all.

rufus plungemongrel Wrote:
17/07/2011
Why is Daw Aung San Suu Kyi silent about China's role in her fatherland. Is it because of embarrassment over her intransigent support for sanctions, which have handed Burma to China on a golden lacquer-ware plate.

TAH Wrote:
15/07/2011
Chinese now doing business in Burma are unethical half-human people who flagrantly don't care about the wellfare of Burmese society and its environment. This way they are just inviting the severe racial riot that is currently brewing. As this article points out, they have no idea traditionally what corporate social responsibility.

Thein Win Wrote:
15/07/2011
Chinese are doing all bad things in Burma.

MA HOTE TA YOKE.
MA HOTE TAR HMAN THA HMYA TA YOKE A KON LOKE.

tocharian Wrote:
14/07/2011
For millennia, Han Chinese have viewed the periphery as populated by barbarians and it is a mark of Chinese history to “civilize”, “pacify” and “sinicize” these regions (bring them under Chinese cultural, political, economic and demographic control). Chinese society is convinced of their cultural superiority, especially over those lazy backward neighbouring "tribes"in Burma. They might view the "West" as a "worthy adversary" that they have to compete against but Southeast Asians are not looked upon by the Chinese as "equals".

Chinese are stealing away the natural resources destroying the natural landscape and culture of Burma. They might soon be scraping away the gold from the pagodas.

Zaw Min Wrote:
14/07/2011
Another well thought out and written article from Irrawaddy. The Chinese, as well as the Indians, Thais, Bangladeshis, Laotians - the neighbors - as well as those from afar will come if there is opportunity for mutual benefit and growth. But so far the growth of China in Myanmar is for the Chinese and the two governments only to which the military government will not see but the Chinese government and Chinese are likely to see. So it is most likely as pointed out in the end of the articles that the Chinese are coming and they will stay on long if they follow the comments in this article. But they, together with the Myanmar leaders are in for a big messy fight if they don't heed the word of caution in the article.

More Articles in This Section

bullet Sizing Up an Icon

bullet Fighting Corruption Begins at Home

bullet Future of Exiled Burmese Media

bullet How Much Freedom Does Burmese Media Enjoy?

bullet Five Days in Burma

bullet Turning Burma into Next Asian Tiger No Simple Task

bullet With Suu Kyi On Board, Is Burma Finally Moving Toward Real Change?

bullet The ‘Rule of Law’ in Burma

bullet New Doors are Opening in Burma

bullet A Good Beginning to the New Year






Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

Donations

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.