ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION | VIDEO





COMMENTARY
Pressure Off Burmese PM
By KYAW ZWA MOE Saturday, October 24, 2009


COMMENTS (4)
RECOMMEND (377)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

CHA-AM, Thailand — Burmese Prime Minister Thein Sein was relaxed at the 15th Asean Summit in the Thai beach town of Hua Hin. The pressure he had felt from his counterparts in earlier meetings of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) had simply evaporated. 

The lack of significant criticsm of Burma at the current meeting, which ends on Sunday, was no doubt even felt by his boss, Sen-Gen Than Shwe, and other junta generals back in Naypyidaw, the capital.  

The lack of criticism doesn’t mean that human rights violations in the military-ruled country have stopped. About 2,100 political prisoners still languish in its notorious jails and pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi is still under an 18-month house arrest.

What’s changed are regional and national factors: the current border dispute between Thailand and Cambodia; the tardy arrival of half of the Asean leaders because of a tropical storm; domestic political matters in the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia and Cambodia; and the negotiations involved in forming an Asean economic community by 2015, which was one of the summit’s chief goals.

More importantly, the diplomatic dance between Burma and the United States in recent weeks has overshadowed Burma’s presence at the summit. A US delegation will visit Burma soon to begin direct talks with junta leaders, part of a new US “engagement policy” announced in September.

At the Asean 2007 summit in Singapore, Thein Sein was pressured by his counterparts after the junta violently suppressed mass demonstrations organized by monks, killing and jailing peaceful protestors, which outraged the world community.

Asean host chair Singapore had invited UN special envoy Ibrahim Gambari to Burma to brief the leaders of 16 Asian countries, including China and Japan, on his visits to Burma after the crackdown.

Thein Sein’s retort: “Nobody has the right to brief on Myanmar but me” caused a diplomatic furor and the invitation was revoked.

Thein Sein and his delegation also faced also Asean pressure at the 14th summit in Feb-Mar this year. The United States, as the strongest vocal critic of the military regime, raised the issue of Burma’s stonewalling on civil rights in one-on-one conversations with delegates. In addition, the civil society representatives highlighted the issue of the scores of Rohingya, who had fled Burma to Thailand by boat, to escape harsh economic conditions and discrimination in western Burma.

In July this year, Burmese Foreign Minister Nyan Win was the focus of Asean pressure at the ministerial meeting of the Asean Regional Forum. At that time, Suu Kyi, who was due to be released in May, faced trial, following the bizarre intrusion of an American into her Rangoon lakeside compound. Apart from her trial, international concerns also centered on Burma’s military ties with North Korea and the issue of nuclear weapons.

During this summit, Then Sein did manage to inject himself into the current tension between Thailand and Cambodia, following a war of words after Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen offered sanctuary to fugitive ex-Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra.

Thein Sein reportedly told the Thai prime minister that Burma would not allow anyone to use its soil as a springboard to attack Thailand.

Even though the pressure was off Thein Sein at this summit, the Burma issue didn’t go away entirely. On Saturday, Asean leaders again called on the junta to conduct free and fair elections in 2010, but avoided criticizing it directly.

The statement read: “We underscore the importance of achieving national reconciliation and that the general elections to be held in Myanmar [Burma] in 2010 must be conducted in a fair, free, inclusive and transparent manner in order to be credible to the international community.”

Thai Foreign Minister Kasit Piromya told reporters late Saturday that Asean didn’t take tougher measures this time because there were positive developments, such as the direct contact between Suu Kyi and the military regime and between the US and the regime. He said, however, Asean’s policy remains firm in terms of calling for the release of all political prisoners and including opposition groups in the upcoming election.

The diplomatic pressure that Burma has faced in the past has lessened, at least for right now, mostly because it comes at a time when the junta is undertaking face-to-face talks with the US.

However, some Burma watchers believe that Than Shwe is just “buying time” while the junta consolidates more power, as the generals have done over the past two decades.

One thing is clear. It was a mistake for Asean leaders to take a soft approach toward Burma at this summit, before the junta has made any significant progress toward democracy and national reconciliation.



COMMENTS (4)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

Okkar Wrote:
27/10/2009
It seems anyone who doesn't agree with opposition supporters is stupid or naive. I wonder when they will start saying Obama is naive for engaging with the junta.

Tide Wrote:
26/10/2009
Come on... constructive criticisms are welcome, even by the military. But this article sounds like ASEAN is all about Myanmar. Thein Sein was quite right to say that nobody has the right to brief on Myanmar except Myanmar. Irrawaddy articles should be more about qualitative opposition, not about anti-government. There is a fine line between them. You can't criticise everything from Rohingha and Wa issues to polluted water in the Yangon River and officials' corruption at one summit. All of them can't be blended in one pot, and expect the government to solve these issues while you at the same time support the isolation policy.

You have to learn to give credits when they are due as well. Political prisoners number 2,100—this has been more or less the same number for the past 20 years. Our politics should not focus on ASSK and her detention. 42 million in 1988 and now is 52 million of Myanmar. While you demand the military to change mentality, shouldn't The Irrawaddy contributors/reports change mentality too?

timothy Wrote:
25/10/2009
Asean and Thai foreign minister have again successfully been fooled by the Junta without any significant development happening in Burma.

Thein Sein happily goes back to Burma and the rest is business as usual.

Than Shwe knew how to deal with international pressure. Until real life-threatening danger affects him, Than Shwe will never ever surrender to democracy. THIS IS THE TRUTH. Asean leaders are either very stupid or naive.

pLan B Wrote:
25/10/2009
I feel sorry for Ko Kyaw Zwa Moe as he must hate to admit that in the current state of affairs the SPDC is in the driver's seat of Asean as well as the next western moveand the relationship with China.

One does not have to be a genius to consider all possible outcome.

However questions remain:

1) Will SPDC finally grab this truly last chance to reform and thus assure themselves as true patriots as they thought themselves to be but have proven otherwise so far?

2) Will the west continue to treat the SPDC as a Banana Republic government and thus continue policies that it finds shameful to mention let alone admit?

3) Will China do the "right thing" for her national interest economically, no matter what form of government follows after the SPDC?

More Articles in This Section

bullet Sizing Up an Icon

bullet Fighting Corruption Begins at Home

bullet Future of Exiled Burmese Media

bullet How Much Freedom Does Burmese Media Enjoy?

bullet Five Days in Burma

bullet Turning Burma into Next Asian Tiger No Simple Task

bullet With Suu Kyi On Board, Is Burma Finally Moving Toward Real Change?

bullet The ‘Rule of Law’ in Burma

bullet New Doors are Opening in Burma

bullet A Good Beginning to the New Year






Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

Donations

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.