ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION | VIDEO





COMMENTARY
Than Shwe’s ‘Mercy’ is Meaningless
By KYAW ZWA MOE Tuesday, August 11, 2009


COMMENTS (11)
RECOMMEND (396)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

The notorious Insein Prison court sentenced Aung San Suu Kyi to three years imprisonment with hard labor around noon on Tuesday. Hold your anger. Mercy then dropped from above. Her captor, Snr-Gen Than Shwe, interfered with the court’s harsh decision by halving her sentence and allow her to return home. Thank God. Oh no!  Thank Than Shwe.  

As soon as the court read the verdict, Home Minister Maj-Gen Maung Oo entered the courtroom like the Deus ex Machina of classical Greek drama and announced that Than Shwe, head of the ruling junta, had ordered the sentence cut to 18 months. Than Shwe said in his statement, read to the court by the minister, that he had issued the order for four reasons—Suu Kyi is the daughter of Aung San, Burma’s independence hero, in the interests of the country’s peace and stability, and for the absence of grudges and to avoid obstacles on the way towards democracy.

Apart from halving her sentence, said the minister, Than Shwe had ruled that she would serve the 18 months at home, under house arrest. But the merciful gestures didn’t stop there—Maung Oo said Suu Kyi could expect an amnesty if she complied with the disciplines the government would set up during that time.

Under the terms of this new house arrest order, Suu Kyi can receive visits from her doctor and other guests, watch state-run TV and read approved newspapers.

Two of Suu Kyi’s women companions were also recipients of Than Shwe’s benevolence. The two members of Suu Kyi’s National League for Democracy, who were also convicted of giving shelter to the American intruder John W Yettaw, had their sentences halved. Yettaw wasn’t so lucky—he was sentenced to a total of seven years hard labor.

Than Shwe’s intervention in the trial indicated that he and his regime want to counter international criticism of their treatment of Suu Kyi by cultivating an image of a constructive and merciful leader, even though their kangaroo court had condemned an innocent person.

Despite her innocence, Suu Kyi—who has spent 14 of the past 20 years under house arrest—is seen by the generals as the most dangerous person on earth, capable of destroying their planned election in 2010.

When she went on trial in May, Suu Kyi faced a possible prison sentence of five years. The minimum sentence for her “crime” was three years, and most observers expected this would be her punishment.

Basically, the generals wanted to keep Suu Kyi locked up until after the 2010 election. A sentence of 18 months served their purpose and gave an aura of clemency to the court.

The junta had anyway inserted in the constitution approved by a referendum in 2008 a provision excluding Suu Kyi from the highest public office. The Article 59—Qualifications of the President and Vice-President Article—states: “The President of the Union himself, parents, spouse, children and their spouses shall not owe allegiance to a foreign country, nor be subject of a foreign or citizen of a foreign country.”

That article automatically bars Suu Kyi from any leadership role as she is the widow of a British scholar and mother of two sons who are not Burmese citizens.

However, that is not enough for the generals. Her conviction now on a trumped-up charge actually bars her from participating in the political arena for ever.
 
The constitution’s Article 121 states that a person serving a prison term or having been convicted for an offence shall not be entitled to be elected to parliament. That clearly means that Suu Kyi can never stand for election.  

Than Shwe seems to be saying: “Suu Kyi, see you after our election.”  He could add, however, “But we’ll never see each other in the political arena.”



COMMENTS (11)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

paday Wrote:
16/08/2009
Sound like Daddy Pauphaw wrote the script,
or could be Lady Macbeth Kyaing Kyaing
watching too many Kung Fu movies. Thu
Daw Kaung Kyet Tha Kho Than Shwe. Bout
face trying to make himself look good.
But everyone knows trumped up charges in
Kangaroo court. Judges just reading out
script handed out by Than Shwe, Burma
is a lawless country, everything goes by
Than Shwe's law, period. Who is he trying
to fool, not even his subordinates? They
all are scared to lose their lives and
their livelihood. Burma's junta is a
laughing stock in the world's eyes.



pLan B Wrote:
13/08/2009
Dr Hla Than
Thank you. "Until one realize the nature of the beast" the options available for application can not be formulated.
Thailand learnt that long ago, so did China.

Dr Hla Than Wrote:
13/08/2009
This psywarfare master cunningly played his trial of DASSK against the world community and comes up the winner. He was searching for proper excuse to do so. He sensationalised the trial. He wished from the very beginning to lock her up under house arrest, but by threatening harsh prison terms and showing magnanimity by reducing it to house arrest-he has shown the the world community what a formidable foe he is.

chanlawn Wrote:
13/08/2009
Than shwe and his kangaroo court have already orchestrated the trial. Than Shwe let the court give Suu Kyi a harsh sentence so that he could save her to show that he is a good man, or to relieve pressure from international outcry. If Than shwe let the court sentence Suu Kyi to three years in prison with hard labor, a mass demostration would occur. Than Shwe cannot let that happen. So he keeps her under house arrest for another 18 months to be sure that she cannot not interfere with the next year election, which he believes that will elect him as the King of Burma

Okkar Wrote:
12/08/2009
If you dont want his mercy, there's always the option of 3 years hard labour sentence. Feel free to advise Su Kyi to take that alternative!

One minute they want her to be set free, the next minute they complain that she got lesser sentence!! Make your mind up you crazy people!

Yangontha Wrote:
12/08/2009
Of course, Than Shwe’s "Mercy" is meaningless to everybody in Burma, except to his family, who also may not have any mercy like him in one day for he is a "Mad Monster", sitting around with his Chinese guns in his hands in a Junta's merry-go-around to find a political rival in the Burmese political arena, where most of the political prisoners are nearly dead (mentally and physically). What a show?

Tom Tun Wrote:
12/08/2009
Tyrant act as bloody merciful throne. What is Burmese political system? When did it comes down to Monarchy?

First, DASSK is innocent of all charges. She was held captive, how could she be guilty of charges for intrusion of someone? Ungrateful Than Shwe is intentionally rewinding the history of Burma. After 2010 a puppet government will form and stability will erode and there will be another coup and we will all go back to 1962 again.

Why are these people so stupid and still not willing to do the right thing? Today is the day that justice was silenced in Burma as deaf ears. Darkness covers the light of rightouness.

We have no other choice but to fight for our freedom with violence. Life is so dear, freedom is so sweet, but it is time to choose to live as slaves or die as a free man.

LuuSoeLay Wrote:
12/08/2009
I have been taught that "there is no one above the law". It turns out that this statement is incorrect for Burma. I don't know when the laws have been rewritten or always been.

This is a shameful intervene upon court's decision to overturn by a leader of country. Neither I am not a lawyer nor familiar with laws. Clearly one can tell what is in the mind of old fox with two heart-strokes. One more heart-stroke and he will be in meat market, says on election day?

KKK Wrote:
12/08/2009
Than Shwe has no mercy, no kindness, no love, no forgiveness, no commpassion. Than Shwe has anger, brutality, cruelty, devilishness, evil deeds, foolishness, greed, hatred, impoliteness, jealousy, pride, and selfishness.

Sein Win Wrote:
12/08/2009
Now that Than Shwe has deliberately sentenced Daw Suu, he thinks he and his group can cling to power and carry on.

It is time for the People of Burma to open their wide eyes and be united. Whatever Election they do, the People should either boycott or refrain from casting their ballots to any members of the SPDC party members.

Now Aung Thaung Kyaw Hsan, Htay Oo and Soe Tha are believed to be forming a party to participate in the election. No matter what, the entire people inclusive of the working class hand in hand with the public, students should get together unitedly and cast their precious ballots on parties that are not hand in gloves with the junta.

Likewise it is an open secret that Than Shwe has also told his most trusted crook, Tay Za, to form a party comprising of Merchants, entrepenuers, business associates and others that they can trust to form a party enticing local citizens like the farmers and villagers of the poor standards in giving financial assistance, buy votes.

timothy Wrote:
12/08/2009
Than Shwe had shown his real image now that UN should understand their past mistakes.

UN should use the punitive acts, forceful demands and equally effective physical measures to tightening the screws on Junta.

UN should further declare the economic and arms embargo towards the Junta. Any countries try to break the sanction rules must be punished with heavy financial penalties. UN should make themselves ready to punish China, Russia and North Korea.

Chinese companies resisting international pressure to leave Burma should be fined according to law. People will boycott the products of these companies.

More Articles in This Section

bullet Sizing Up an Icon

bullet Fighting Corruption Begins at Home

bullet Future of Exiled Burmese Media

bullet How Much Freedom Does Burmese Media Enjoy?

bullet Five Days in Burma

bullet Turning Burma into Next Asian Tiger No Simple Task

bullet With Suu Kyi On Board, Is Burma Finally Moving Toward Real Change?

bullet The ‘Rule of Law’ in Burma

bullet New Doors are Opening in Burma

bullet A Good Beginning to the New Year






Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

Donations

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.