ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION | VIDEO





COMMENTARY
No Holiday for Nyan Win in Phuket
By YENI Thursday, July 23, 2009


COMMENTS (9)
RECOMMEND (340)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

If Burma’s Foreign Minister Nyan Win thought he was going to enjoy a bit of a holiday on Thailand’s resort island of Phuket this week, he must have been badly disappointed. Instead, the meetings of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) he attended turned out to be a nightmare for him.

The junta representative at the Asean Ministerial Meeting (AMM) and Asean Regional Forum (ARF) found himself floundering, fending off diplomatic pressures and fielding press conference questions about human rights abuses in his country and, more seriously, the nature of relations with North Korea.

These high-profile Asean meetings come as Aung San Suu Kyi is about to face final arguments in her trial for allegedly violating the terms of her house arrest. The trial has drawn condemnation from the regional and international community.

At an informal working dinner, Nyan Win told other Asean foreign ministers that his government had not ruled out acquiescing to UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon’s demand for the release of Suu Kyi and other political prisoners.

Asean added its voice to Ban’s demands, and also called for free, fair and inclusive elections in 2010. Notably, Indonesian Foreign Minister Hassan Wirayuda said: "We have been saying to them (the Burmese junta) directly that the process must be inclusive for all groups in society ... including Aung San Suu Kyi."

Nyan Win told his counterparts that he would “report back" to Naypyidaw.

Besides Suu Kyi’s trial, another concern relating to Burma is its increasing military ties with North Korea. According to Asean Director-General Vitavas Srivihok, the issue of closer relations between Burma and North Korea was discussed at a meeting of the Southeast Asian Nuclear Weapon-Free Zone (SEANWFZ) commission which was set up in July 2007 and tasked with ensuring that member countries follow the best safety practices in running nuclear power plants.

Malaysia, Thailand and Vietnam have all announced plans to build nuclear power plants by at least 2020. But Burma is different. Its nuclear ambitions are unclear and there’s uncertainty whether its nuclear technology is for military or civilian purposes.

Security analysts suspect that North Korea has been helping the Burmese junta since the 1990s to develop its tunnel and underground warfare capabilities, as well as providing mid-range missile and nuclear technology.

US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, who attended Asia's biggest security forum, said Washington was taking "very seriously" reports of conventional military cooperation between the two pariah states, adding that such developments would be "destabilizing for the region."

Clinton told Thailand’s Nation TV: "We worry about the transfer of nuclear technology" from North Korea to Burma's repressive junta.

Meanwhile, Nyan Win and his team avoided the press as much as possible. When The Irrawaddy's reporters asked Thet Tun, a senior diplomat in the Burmese government delegation in Phuket, about North Korean nuclear ambitions, he replied curtly but politely: "I could not answer these questions."

In fact, the difficulty Nyan Win has experienced under pressure in Phuket suggests he will get very little co-operation from his boss Snr-Gen Than Shwe.

For instance, as Burma’s military authorities denied permission for Suu Kyi's lawyers to meet her to finalize the draft of their closing statements two days before her trial resumes for final arguments, the junta stonewalled its Phuket delegation led by Nyan Win.

Nyan Win is likely to face further uncomfortable Asean sessions between now and the 2010 election, when he will have to resign his post. It’s possible that he will refuse to attend further meetings—following the lead of North Korean Foreign Minister Pak Ui-Chun, who sent his ambassador to the Phuket meeting rather than subject himself to the kind of pressure encountered by Nyan Win.



COMMENTS (9)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

KKK Wrote:
27/07/2009
To Okkar: Burmese people are not suffering. We have plenty of food to eat. We are very rich in natural resources. Our Irrawaddy Delta region can feed the whole of Burma. We have millions of acres of forest. We are producing trillions of cubic feet of gas a day. We are builing hundreds of hydro power gens and gas turbine gens evey year. We are even exporting electricity to our neighboring countries. We have world standard five star hotels around the country. We have several international standard colleges and universities. We are even offering PhDs. You're totally wrong, Okkar. We are not suffering, we are enjoying our lives. We don't care about sanctions as long as we have our "Swe Myo Pauk Phaw" and "Northern style Kimchi." Our military is very strong. We leaders are very smart. We don't care about sanctions.

Okkar Wrote:
26/07/2009
Andrew Bowe,

Burma did not isolate itself. Opposition groups and their supporters called for Burma to be isolated through sanctions and cutting off diplomatic relations. The opposition's strategy has become their own undoing and contributed to isolation and torturing of their own people. If you are feeling sick to your stomach, perhaps you should go and let this out on nearest opposition groups office. There you may find them enjoying their privileged life styles while people in Burma are suffering.

bo san tin Wrote:
25/07/2009
The junta bumpkins have long range plans in digging the tunnels with their ill-found wealth. The tunnels are more secure as a conduit to their next existence vs being buried/cremated at Yay Way. Possibly, perhaps 50 years or more later, their bones in the tunnels will become a tourist attraction?

Andrew Bowe Wrote:
24/07/2009
This story should make this man feel sick to his stomach because no country like Burma or N Korea should ever isolate and torture their own people. Those generals in both countries are evil and not human, they are animals, It's about time women should balance and hold a man's power in check because woman are the future not men in the case of army generals of both countries

planB Wrote:
24/07/2009
"Than Shwe is not intelligent enough how to run the country. But he is a dictator like Ne Win and Saddan Hussein,does not allow to speak back and let him corrected."

1)This is the typical mentality of the majority of forum opinionated that have made the SPDC the way it is.

2)Encourage the EU and the West to be dismissive and offer token empty policy (Banana Republic Approach) that further makes the SPDC and compounds the suffering of the people.

3)Furthermore, prolong the detention of DASSK by not giving her any chance to change her mind or negotiate at will.

4) Giving the SPDC further justification (a low bar) to sell the future of Burma to the others.

Have any one of you "political scholars of infinite distinction" out there ever asked yourself "How can a rotten to the core regime survive 20+ years with the kind of intelligence every one of you wise opinionated attributes to the SPDC."
Now who is more wily?
Who is the fool?

Kyaw Wrote:
23/07/2009
The only solution for Nyan Win is to escape to the US Embassy for political asylum, it will help him to free from being a drop of water in Thanshwe's palm which can be rinsed out any time and anywhere.

Thanshwe has no choice, but to return Burma to the hand of DASSK and apologize politely and ask for mercy. Only by this option, he may save his own life and his kins from the fate like his predecessor Newin.



timothy Wrote:
23/07/2009
Why doesn't Nyan Win seek political asylum in Phuket, tell all the truth about junta`s atrocities and illegal dealings in Burma? Because he has got family back in Burma. They are hostages taken by Junta. Gen Ne Win ended his life under detention of current regime. Than Shwe will follow this unavoidable paths because of his actions and bad Karma.

FF Wrote:
23/07/2009
Nyan Win has no choice.If he commits something which is against his boss Than Shwe, he will be immediately imprisoned like Win Aung and Khin Maung Win. So he is trying to avoid the issues and needs to be polite .

Than Shwe is not intelligent enough how to run the country.But he is a dictator like Ne Win and Saddan Hussein ,does not allow to speak back and let him corrected.

Because of wrong constitution the country is lead by military who are not good at civil arena but do not realise and accept taht they are not good.As they are allowed to abuse by international community for long ,they are used to it .Now, it is very difficult by international community to change .We believe they will go further in opposite dirrection likem Japanese soldiers who never let captured but take their lives by themselves.

In other words Junta is heading its wrong pathway and international community is leading their correct way.Two parallel lines will never ever meet again at the expense of many lives.

Ashame.

Yangontha Wrote:
23/07/2009
Nyan Win does not know what nightmare is for him for he is just a messenger from the junta's regime, who usually enjoys almost everything whenever he has a chance, for he knows that his time is quite limited in the ministry and this is normal way of practice for every member of the regime, since 1962.

More Articles in This Section

bullet Sizing Up an Icon

bullet Fighting Corruption Begins at Home

bullet Future of Exiled Burmese Media

bullet How Much Freedom Does Burmese Media Enjoy?

bullet Five Days in Burma

bullet Turning Burma into Next Asian Tiger No Simple Task

bullet With Suu Kyi On Board, Is Burma Finally Moving Toward Real Change?

bullet The ‘Rule of Law’ in Burma

bullet New Doors are Opening in Burma

bullet A Good Beginning to the New Year






Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

Donations

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.