ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION | VIDEO






Confusing Testimony, Conflicting Reports Emerge from Yettaw Trial
By YENI Thursday, May 28, 2009


COMMENTS (11)
RECOMMEND (551)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

Confusing testimony and conflicting reports have emerged from the trial of John William Yettaw, the 53-year-old American whose uninvited visit to Aung San Suu Kyi’s home triggered a criminal case against her.

Burma’s state-run The New Light of Myanmar today reported that Yettaw had testified on Wednesday that he did not swim across Inya Lake to Suu Kyi’s compound, but had instead “walked along the bund of Inya Lake through [sic] the drain.”

A handout photo by Myanmar News Agency and taken on May 13 and released on May 14, shows US citizen John William Yettaw (3rd L on the table) talking to the second secretary consul of the US embassy Colin P. Surst and surrounded by Burmese officials and special police officers at the Aung Thapyey police detention centre in Rangoon.
Speaking to The Irrawaddy after Yettaw’s testimony, Suu Kyi’s lawyer Kyi Win said that when making his statement, the American had motioned with his arms in a pumping action as if walking quickly, but not as if he were swimming.

During nearly three hours of questioning, the former US-Vietnam War veteran from Falcon, Missouri, repeatedly said he “walked though” the lake to reach Suu Kyi's house, according to lawyers who spoke to The Irrawaddy.

The lawyers could not ascertain, however, whether Yettaw was referring to his first visit to Suu Kyi’s compound in November or to both visits.

How exactly he was able to traverse the 5-meter (15-foot) deep lake by foot was not clarified.

When a prosecution lawyer asked Yettaw whether he was making this statement about “walking through” the lake for the first time, Yettaw replied that he had repeatedly told police this during his interrogation, but the police officers did not record the details.

John William Yettaw in a 2005 photo released by his family. (Photo: AP)
The banks of Inya Lake are blocked by security restrictions at many points and the lake is too deep to “walk through,” even at its perimeter. Local residents also say the lake is strewn with thick reeds and undergrowth.

The confusion over the testimony and the doubts it raises over whether his nocturnal swim across Inya Lake was, in fact, physically possible, is compounded by the disparity in reports from Burma’s official media.

It is still far from clear how Yettaw entered the Nobel Peace Prize laureate’s lakeside residence on May 3.

According to lawyers who were present in the courtroom, when Yettaw, a Mormon, took the stand for the first time he told the court that he was "sent by God" to warn both her and the Burmese junta of a "terrorist plot” to assassinate her.

The pro-junta media also reported on Wednesday's testimonies by Suu Kyi’s two companions—Khin Khin Win and Win Ma Ma—who are also on trial.

According to The New Light of Myanmar, both women stated that they had heard Yettaw “moaning” outside the house; Khin Khin Win testified that this happened at about 3:30 a.m. She said she found a man lying outside the house and informed Suu Kyi. Both women testified that Yettaw was not let into the house until it was light.

Yettaw reportedly collaborated this evidence, saying that he lay down near the back door due to cramp in both legs and tiredness. According to the official media, Yettaw then stated that he “entered the residence easily as the back door was not locked.”

According to a lawyer who spoke to The Irrawaddy, Yettaw also testified that when he left Suu Kyi's house on the occasion of his first visit on November 30, 2008, a policeman spotted him and pointed a gun at him. The policeman then shouted: “What are you doing?" According to the lawyer, Yettaw stated that the guard allowed him to continue to the lake after he responded by saying, “I'm coming back.”

However, official Burmese media did not report how Yettaw entered and left the compound on his second visit on May 3-5.



1  |  2 



COMMENTS (11)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

U Maung Gyi Wrote:
01/06/2009
Surely they will jail both Aung San and Aung San Suu Kyi, because both names are attached to Daw Suu's name. Than Shwe wants to jail Aung San Su Kyi because he wants to jail General Aung San due to his fortune teller telling him that he must jail Aung San, other wise he will go to hell.

Moe Aung Wrote:
01/06/2009
KKK,

Absolutely. She's won the people's love and respect; they've earned only hatred and disgust.

KKK Wrote:
01/06/2009
To Moe Aung:

Than Shwe and followers hate DASSK becasue Burmese people love DASSK and Burmese people respect DASSK. No one respects Than Shwe and no one loves Than Shwe. It's all about jealousy.

Moe Aung Wrote:
29/05/2009
rart khi na,

"I'm just wondering why Than Shwe and followers hate Aung San Suu Kyi."

Elementary. She represents the people and they represent only themselves. An irreconcilable conflict of interest as far as they are concerned.

rart khi na Wrote:
29/05/2009
I'm just wondering why Than Shwe and followers hate Aung San Suu Kyi. What has she done to them? She just wanted her own country to be developed the same as other countries. Why do they want to harm her instead of getting advice from her to make the better country for all poor people. Not only does she pity her own peoples living in Burma, we do feel very sad for our own country. It's not necessary to conpare with other Asean countries. It's time to change forward in a good direction from now on.

Blake Wrote:
29/05/2009
Jeg: While I am not willing to assume that the guards can speak English, and language barriers are a relevant point, as you say, it is worth mentioning that since Myanmar is a former British colony English is widely spoken. I would go as far as to say that it is likely that he would be addressed in English, since he so obviously a westerner.

And none of what I say should take away from the fact that this whole thing is a farce. I personally think that his man (Yettaw) may be being manipulated by the junta.

The fact that Suu Kyi was slated for release on May 27th, before all of this began, is all the motivation that the junta required. That and the fact that "elections" are looming next year.

anita Wrote:
29/05/2009
I never waste my time and air for the lies of the junta.

If it is not possible to bring it to justice by the international human right community, the junta will continue to commit the sins however they like.

I am quite surprised why this handful of people, the junta, is recognised by people outside Myanmar.

Jeg Wrote:
29/05/2009
The policeman shouted: “What are you doing?" Yettaw responded by saying, “I'm coming back.” Does Yettaw speak Burmese? Does the "policeman" or whoever speak English? Was Yettaw trained with a few answers to possible questioning from the security officers? For a foreigner he crosses pretty well the language barrier.

nono Wrote:
29/05/2009
The Myanmar Alin or the New Light of Myanmar news are very funny. I live in Burma and I know many things about what is going on in it and I think all people in Burma know more than me. They write the news not for the event but for their stomachs. If you read in this SPDC mouthpiece Myanmar Alin, Burma is like heaven. But come and see the hell of Myanmar and compare it to what the Myanmar Alin said.

Dave Wrote:
28/05/2009
This "trial" is as bizarre as it is tragic. Unbelievable stuff.

Oparlay Wrote:
28/05/2009
The guy is insane and the whole situation is a waste of time and effort. He probably just tried to make up some story to write in his book.

One thing I can say in this country is that the government servants are not allowed to talk to foreigners and they normally are intimidated for such encounters. I can imagine that the guard easily ignored the situation and let the man go away quickly because he did not want to get in trouble by talking to the foreigner. He will just pretend by not seeing him. Some foreign diplomats live in that area so the guard may think that Yettaw belongs to one of the embassies. But when they could not hide the situation, they of course have to report and the guards probably made up the story.

I wish we know who that bloody fool is. He costs lots of people their time, energy and causes hatred among each other. Get him out of the country quickly and never let him come back.

More Articles in This Section

bullet 'My Wife Died From Police Abuse,' Says Husband

bullet US Says Observer Conditions Don't Meet Int'l Standards

bullet 159 Observers to Monitor Burma Election

bullet Govt to Address Breaches of SSA-South Ceasefire: Aung Min

bullet Burma Investors Pin Hopes on Seminal Sunday

bullet Malaysia PM Leads 50-Strong Delegation to Burma

bullet US Congress to Assess Burma's Political Prisoner Issue

bullet Rangoon Woman in Police Station Death Plunge

bullet Burmese Legal System Remains Tool of Govt: AHRC

bullet Burmese Army Chief Defends Political Role






Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

Donations

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.