The Irrawaddy News Magazine [Covering Burma and Southeast Asia]

Burmese Abroad Welcome Tax Break, but More Reforms Needed
By SIMON ROUGHNEEN Tuesday, January 10, 2012

BANGKOK — The decision by the Burmese government to end the practice of collecting income tax from migrant workers abroad has been welcomed by Burmese across Southeast Asia, but some say that more needs to be done to make life easier for millions of Burmese working across the region.

In late 2011, the Burmese government announced that workers abroad would be exempt from Jan. 1, 2012, from paying a 10 percent salary levy, deemed by many to be an onerous and unjustifiable burden given that workers paid taxes in the country where they lived and worked.

In interviews last year, Burmese migrants in Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand all railed against the levy, which had to be paid if Burmese nationals wished to renew their passport at the country's embassy.

Kyaw Kyaw, a Burmese national living in Singapore, told The Irrawaddy by email: “I'm glad to hear that tax has been removed. All the people are happy about that news.”

However, despite the new waiver, Kyaw Kyaw still has to pay up for taxes owed last year. “My passport needs to be renewed at the end of this month, so I need to pay around 3,000 Singapore dollars in taxes to the Myanmar [Burmese] embassy. I got a lot of headache from this problem,” he added.

The Burmese government announced the tax reform as part of a series of reforms that also includes changes to the banking system and rules allowing the formation of trade unions. U Chit Shein, the director-general of the Department of Labor in Naypyidaw, said in a recent telephone interview that “the Myanmar government is very interested in this issue and as per President Thein Sein’s speech on March 30, 2011, will work to ensure worker rights both in Myanmar and abroad.”

However, some Burmese overseas say that more needs to be done. Tun Tun, head of the Burma Campaign Malaysia, an NGO that assists Burmese workers in Malaysia, said that the end of the income tax “is a very good decision for our migrants,” but criticized the passport application process at the Burmese embassy in Kuala Lumpur as slow and bureaucratic.

Some who applied for passports in October are still waiting to receive them, he said. “Other nationalities, such as Nepalese or Indonesians, which have a lot of migrant workers here, too, get their passports much faster.”

Burmese passports are valid for just three years, compared with 10 for most other countries, meaning that Burmese migrants have to undertake the time-consuming process much more often than others. “It should be for 10 years,” said Tun Tun, speaking by telephone from Kuala Lumpur.

While millions of Burmese migrants travel abroad without official documentation and therefore don't have to deal with their embassy or pay Burmese tax, the legal vacuum leaves them vulnerable to exploitation and trafficking, particularly in Malaysia and Thailand.

The Malaysian and Thai authorities have introduced measures to enable migrants to register legally, which means migrants need to acquire passports from their home countries.

Migrants send hundreds of millions of dollars back to impoverished families every year, and the Burmese government and banks see a business opportunity. On Nov. 25, 2011, the Central Bank of Myanmar granted eleven private banks permits trade foreign currencies.

Andy Hall, a migrant worker advocate at Mahidol University in Bangkok, said that the Burmese government is trying to formalize remittances through the banking sector, which might be a challenge given that an informal money transfer system, or hundi, enables Burmese abroad to send money back to families even in remote areas where banks are not present.

“It will be difficult for banks to compete with that network,” said Hall, who added that “there is a lot of concern among migrants that the bank fees will be high.”

The Burmese government is said to envisage a longer-term Philippines-style policy where emigration is supported as a means of compensating for a stagnant or under-performing domestic economy. A tenth of Filipinos live overseas, and money that “OFWs” (overseas Filipino workers) remit makes up approximately the same percentage of the country’s economy.

A study published by the World Bank in 2008 estimated that Burmese remittances formally totaled US $150 million. However, other studies suggest that the total could be three to four times that amount. With the bulk of the money coming through the hundi system, a precise measurement is impossible.

Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group | www.irrawaddy.org