ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION | VIDEO





COMMENTARY
Is the Myitsone Dam Burma’s WMD?
By AUNG ZAW Monday, September 26, 2011


COMMENTS (8)
RECOMMEND (456)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

For the last several years, there has been rumors and speculation that Burma’s military junta was attempting to secretly build or acquire a nuclear weapon. But now the country’s new quasi-civilian government is unapologetically charging ahead with the construction of a potential weapon of mass destruction right in front of everybody’s eyes—the Myitsone Dam.

Aung Zaw is founder and editor of the Irrawaddy magazine. He can be reached at [email protected].

Located on the Irrawaddy River in Kachin State just 1.6 km below the confluence of the Mali and N'Mai rivers, the Myitsone Dam project has already displaced thousands of residents and will displace many more once it is completed and 766 sq km are flooded to create a giant reservoir. In addition, the negative environmental and social impacts of building a dam at the source of Burma’s most important waterway will harm the lives of millions of people not just in Kachin State, but throughout the country. Last but certainly not least, because the dam is being built less than 100 km from a major tectonic fault line, if an earthquake causes the massive dam to break then the loss of life would be catastrophic.

As a result, protests against the Myitsone Dam have been growing, with activists inside and outside of Burma coordinating their efforts and joining the Kachin Independence Army and the people of Kachin State—who have been fighting against the construction of the dam since its conception—in a push to stop the joint China-Burma hydropower project .

In what has now been coined the “Save the Irrawaddy” campaign, many scholars, publishers, journalists, activists and public figures have been at the forefront, actively educating the public and advocating a halt to the dam project, which was begun without any public participation in the decision making process. The movement has gained momentum through the use of Internet social networking sites such as Facebook, and last week in-person events were held around Rangoon, with many of Burma’s prominent intellectuals, politicians, students and activists gathering to show campaign solidarity.

At the “Save the Irrawaddy” art exhibition, more than 100 photographs, paintings, drawings and cartoons were displayed, although Burma’s censorship officials inspected the show in advance and removed some cartoons that were critical of the government.

Burma’s Pro-democracy leader and Nobel Peace Prize Winner Aung San Suu Kyi attended the exhibition, and told those present that, “People need to unite if they are to achieve what they want,” a message implying that the campaign to stop the Myitsone Dam could also become a rallying point for Burma’s opposition forces and ethnic minorities in their efforts to bring democracy and human rights to the country.

The “Save the Irrawaddy” campaign was recently fueled by Zaw Min, Burma’s minister of electric power, who arrogantly announced that the government would continue with the Myitsone Dam project regardless of the public outcry.

“We'll keep working on the Myitsone Project. We'll never back down. We won't halt this project in spite of objections from environmental groups,” said Zaw Min, who asserted that the dam will not affect water levels on the river nor have any adverse environmental effects.

Zaw Min also said that the dam would be constructed in a fashion that ensures safety for nearly one thousand years, but critics argue that other Chinese-built dams have poor safety records and the world's largest, the Three Gorges Dam, has caused urgent environmental, geological and social problems.

If the Burmese government continues to thumb its nose at the public campaign in this fashion, it is likely that the protests will grow even louder and stronger and could in fact turn into a bigger social movement.

In any event, the anti-Mytisone Dam protests will no doubt test President Thein Sein and his new government, which came to power in a sham election orchestrated by the former military junta. It was this previous regime that signed the dam project agreement with China and contracted with AsiaWorld, a private Burmese company, for construction of the dam. AsiaWorld and its owner, Steven Law, are on the US and EU sanctions list.



1  |  2 



COMMENTS (8)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

Howard Yeong Wrote:
06/10/2011
Those claiming the dam will do nothing but evil must have been living in their luxurious electricity powered house, without any mercy of people living in darkness all the years.
Democracy is important, out rights are important, but that does not mean we should uphold the "Not In My Back Yard" mentality as the American do.
Be cautious about those who cry afoul of the dam project with some hidden political agenda. They are using ignorant Burmese people as their political tools for their personal political gains.
Power shortage creates the greatest inequality in our country. No electricity, no hope of development and elimination of poverty. Think about it!

Howard Yeong Wrote:
06/10/2011
I think those people living without electricity should unite and demonstrate that the people of Burma deserve a decent life and the government should give revision to the dam project to protect the environment and carry on it, instead of canceling it once for all.

Min Nway Wrote:
30/09/2011
If we allow China to complete Myitson Dam
they will become more aggressive and takeover Shan State sooner than expected.

Burmese Tat Ma Daw is nothing but the gang
of thugs only good at bullying monks and students and raping girls.

Now, we are so sad as the lady is in their pocket.

China knows very well that Burma has no suicide bombers, easy to bully, bribe and take over.

tocharian Wrote:
29/09/2011
@Jericho

UWSA is basically a Chinese proxy army operating in Burma.

I agree with you that the old masters (Western countries) are too broke (I pay my taxes in the West!) to support democratic movements in Burma and to give political asylum to all these Burmese refugees.

Perhaps the West should just let Burma become a Chinese colony. There are other problems in the world. You are right, I have to "look at things in a broader Chinese context" and I shouldn't care too much about the fate of the poor Burmese and just do this greedy stock market thing to get rich. Thanks for the advice!

I wish you good luck with picking the right Chinese stocks and learning how to speak Mandarin, if that's what makes you happy.

chris Jericho Wrote:
28/09/2011
@ tocharian - majority of burmese export, natural gas, goes to thailand. is burma Thailand's colony? canada exports majority of its natural gas and petroleum to the US. is canada the US's colony? I have not seen china sending in its soldiers to burma like the US did with vietnam, or your old master brits did with argentine.
sorry buddy, your old masters are broke. if you want them to come over, you will have to pay bus fares for them.
if there is any lessons learned through living, that would be investing in right stocks at the right time for your present and future. instead of stirring up racial hatred, do yourself a favor and look at things in broader context.

Garrett Wrote:
28/09/2011
Moe Aung wrote:
"What are generals without an army?"

I like your thinking Moe Aung.

Who knows better than the rank & file soldiers of the Tatmadaw which officers are responsible for seeing that the human rights atrocities ordered by the generals are carried out, & which officers showed compassion to the regime's victims?

It really wouldn't take much of a military uprising to convince the generals & other high ranking officers that it is time to go.
I imagine that their trunks are already packed with Euros, gold, & precious stones, & their retirement homes in China & France are ready for immediate occupancy.

It makes me smile to think that there are contingency plans in place by junior officers to intercept the convoys of booty-laden trucks en route to the airbases.
The question is, after taking-out the generals & seizing their wealth, wouldn't those same junior officers have contingency plans to violently put-down any uprising & seize power to become the regime du jour?

tocharian Wrote:
28/09/2011
The sovereignty of Burma as an independent nation is at stake here. This massive dam and the gas/oil pipeline (not to mention the railway along side it) are Chinese projects that are designed by Peking to transform Burma into a vassal state of China, like Tibet. The Chinese are "invading" using the two Y's (Yuans and Y-chromosomes). You might call it "soft power" but the effects (like wind and water on rock) are more devastating and long lasting than the old style of colonialism. I bet that there are 100 times more Chinese "bosses" in Burma now than Brits during the colonial period. These things became clear to me many years ago, after conversations with overseas-Chinese and that's the reason I started posting comments in this and other forums.

By the way, AsiaWorld is just a proxy for Chinese businessmen.

Moe Aung Wrote:
27/09/2011
Makes you wonder if the irony of the situation has escaped the regime's notice.

The two currents of anti-Chinese and anti-govt sentiments are coming together with the potential of turning into a raging torrent. And yet they can't seem to break their life long authoritarian habit of handling dissent. Even the news of this all consuming issue for the entire nation gets the chop from the PSRD.

LET'S CHANNEL IT IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION, NOT A RACE RIOT.

Forge solidarity in a mass movement encompassing all the peoples who feed at the bosom of Mother Irrawaddy, not least the Tatmadaw so we can level the playing field.

Thein Sein vs Shit Lone rivalry may or may not be real. But this is definitely a divisive issue that will arouse anger and passion even inside the regime. Win the army rank and file over to People Power and turn their guns against the generals.

What are generals without an army?
What are officers without troops?
Pull the rug from under them.
UNITE and PREPARE! FIGHT to WIN!

More Articles in This Section

bullet Sizing Up an Icon

bullet Fighting Corruption Begins at Home

bullet Future of Exiled Burmese Media

bullet How Much Freedom Does Burmese Media Enjoy?

bullet Five Days in Burma

bullet Turning Burma into Next Asian Tiger No Simple Task

bullet With Suu Kyi On Board, Is Burma Finally Moving Toward Real Change?

bullet The ‘Rule of Law’ in Burma

bullet New Doors are Opening in Burma

bullet A Good Beginning to the New Year






Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

Donations

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.