Torn Between Two Capitals
By HTET AUNG Wednesday, September 15, 2010


Naypyidaw, a remote town located halfway between Burma's two main cities, Rangoon and Mandalay, has been the country's administrative capital since junta chief Snr-Gen Than Shwe deemed it so on Nov. 6, 2005.

Five years less one day later, as per the 2008 Constitution, Naypyidaw will become a “Union territory” directly governed by the president after the election on Nov. 7.
The political structure of Burma will change after the election; however, the question is: will the political dynamism of the country shift from its old capital, Rangoon, to the new capital whose name translates into English as “The Abode of Kings”?

Traditionally, Rangoon has played the pivotal role in Burmese politics, as well as serving as the country's economic hub ever since colonial times. However, its status was degraded by the military junta when it packed its governmental and administrative bags and moved 200 miles north to an undeveloped site just two miles from Pyinmana.

The construction of the new parliament continued apace with the construction of eight-lane avenues, an international airport and a 24-hour electricity supply, as well as the migration of government officials and their families to the town.

Five years later, Burma's would-be modern metropolis will undergo the transition from a synthetic ghost town to a hive of parliamentary activity. Officially, it will become Burma's first civil administration in two decades.

The new parliament is composed of 31 buildings, as well as presidential mansions for the future president and two vice-presidents.

Synthetic, soulless and desperately devoid of social interaction, Naypyidaw has failed to persuade the staff and families of the United Nations agencies and foreign diplomatic missions to relocate their headquarters and embassies, severely undermining its integrity as a capital city.

The fact is that most ambassadors, diplomats, INGO heads and their families are accustomed to living the high life in whatever country they are assigned. They circulate at cocktail parties, dine at the best restaurants in the city, send their children to the best international schools and constantly receive invitations to glamorous society events.

A far cry from a life in bureaucratic Naypyidaw.

When the Union Election Commission opened its doors for political party registration in March, it was unsurprising that every major national party, bar one, had its headquarters in Rangoon. The exception was, of course, the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP), which based its headquarters in Naypyidaw.

Asked about the political polarization of Rangoon and Naypyidaw, Chan Htun, a veteran politician and a former ambassador to China said: “I see Rangoon continuing to serve as the center of the democratic movement due to some key factors, such as population density, the home of the political parties and the well-established transportation networks linking the country, while Naypyidaw emerges as the fortress of the ruling party.”

But could political tensions between the two cities spill over in the future?

“I don't think so,” said Wun Tha, an elected representative of the National League for Democracy in the 1990 election who currently works as a journalist. “Tension usually raises its head in a formidable situation, for instance, the growing strength of an opposition group threatening or seeking confrontation with the ruling party. What we are witnessing now is the would-be ruling party, the USDP, leaving all the other parties far behind in the race. It feels no threat.”

In the newly emerging political landscape, the leadership of the USDP have chosen isolation in a Naypyidaw where they will quickly fall out of touch with the everyday needs of the people, not to mention their own members in more than 400 branches across the country.

How can Naypyidaw expect to become the heart of the country when it has no soul? It seeks to impress with modernity and money and power, but it lacks cultural, historical, religious and societal roots. Unlike Rangoon, it is not a source of pride to the people of Burma.

Shwedagon Pagoda, the country's most sacred and well-known monument, has stood like a father overlooking Rangoon since the 6th century AD. Like a cheap counterfeiter, Than Shwe tried to imitate the kings of old by ordering the construction of a replica Shwedagon in the new capital.

“Than Shwe considers himself a king,” said Chan Htun. “He built the pagoda as a display of power and as an attempt to create a legacy.”

Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.

Myanmar Pariots Wrote:
Sen.Gen Than-Shwe does not consider himself to be a king but Regent. Sen.Gen can be a President. Then there will be another head of Tatmataw, or Herzog Than-Shwe can retire; we must allow him to retire in peace and comfort. He has done a very very difficult job. The job is not yet finished; all rebels must surrender or join the border guard- a very intelligent solution.
Only through peace we can make progress. In state of war,turmoil or conflict, no civil society can be created. So stop sucking up to so-called right groups, who are just neo-colonialists and neo-imperialists.

Stefan Wrote:
I think Naypyidaw is a nice city. It is a gig distance from anywhere, but it is a nice city.

Marty Myanmar Wrote:
You could take Than Shwe to court over the construction and move to Nay Pyi Daw alone. I believe that in the future there will be such cases. There needs just one case to be brought to court and won, then a flood of cases will ensue.
This capital was built without the consent of anyone, the consensus of anyone except a astrologer, who probably he thought he won't go that far, he thought he would do another 'Yedayar".

Now a lot of people curse him for the move.
There is no flourishing universities or educational institutes or other organizations. Naypyidaw has become a word in a sentence that will normally include a lot of cursing words.

ATK Wrote:
Yangon had no "soul" either, when it became the capital of British Burma. The center of Burmese culture, the heart and soul of Burma was still in Mandalay when the British moved the administrative capital down to a sleepy swamp town and transformed it into what Yangon is today. But the generals really ought to have stuck with moving the capital to near Thanlyin. Then I wouldn't have lost so much money buying up land there, hah. And it would've made more economic sense.

Naypyidaw will never be a Putrajaya (Malaysia's administrative capital). If anything, it looks like a terribly cheap remake.

Moe Aung Wrote:
No contest. Yangon remains the entrepôt and economic hub, and its strategic political importance is unlikely to wane after the sham election with its circus of monkeys dancing to the tune played by the organ grinder at Naypyidaw.

Whoever seizes Yangon in any future conflict (which is only a matter of time since the current farcical 'political solution' will have hardly even touched its root causes) will seize political power. Naypyidaw is destined to wither on the vine.

Surely even the generals' wives and families don't fancy living in Naypyidaw, perhaps more especially them preferring Yangon instead, and can you blame them?

George Than Setkyar Heine Wrote:
Not worth commenting on this one other than saying it is a GHOST town inhabited by ZOMBIES like Than Shwe and his coyotes.

In day time they live under in the tunnels and come out only at night fearing the light and sight of people apparently showing their dislike and disgust of the zombies wearing military uniforms.

Damned the devils and zombies in the tunnels at Naypyidaw is all I have to say!

Kerry Wrote:
Naypyidaw is a joke, and the Burmese military an abomination.

China is entirely culpable, in this absurd and tragic story.

More Articles in This Section

bullet Sizing Up an Icon

bullet Fighting Corruption Begins at Home

bullet Future of Exiled Burmese Media

bullet How Much Freedom Does Burmese Media Enjoy?

bullet Five Days in Burma

bullet Turning Burma into Next Asian Tiger No Simple Task

bullet With Suu Kyi On Board, Is Burma Finally Moving Toward Real Change?

bullet The ‘Rule of Law’ in Burma

bullet New Doors are Opening in Burma

bullet A Good Beginning to the New Year

Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels


Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.