ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION | VIDEO





COMMENTARY
Than Shwe Mulls his Future Role
By AUNG ZAW Friday, March 19, 2010


COMMENTS (10)
RECOMMEND (386)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

Than Shwe issued his long awaited election laws last week and pundits are now wondering whether he will vacate his throne when the voting is over. The fear is that he won't be willing to give up politics and power any time soon.

Sources with access to the top leaders in Naypyidaw say some officials believe Than Shwe is reserving for himself the position of president in post-election Burma, even though he is reported to have told United Nations officials that he planned to retire soon.

Aung Zaw is founder and editor of the Irrawaddy magazine. He can be reached at [email protected]

Military officers and senior civilian officials in Naypyidaw say some factions within the regime want Than Shwe to remain in power indefinitely and have even asked him to “sacrifice” his life by serving the country until the end.

It's no joking matter—Than Shwe will indeed probably consider this  proposal and give it his nod.

Last year, it was rumored that Than Shwe had endorsed the junta's No 3, Gen Thura Shwe Mann, joint chief-of-staff in the armed forces, to become president of post-election Burma. Shwe Mann and his wife are close to Than Shwe and his family, and they are known to go on shopping trips together to Singapore.

However, military sources say Shwe Mann may be now just a spent bullet.  one reason being advanced is that Than Shwe promoted Shwe Mann, the  former commander of the Irrawaddy division to the War Office in Rangoon in the early 2000s just to counter the growing influence of  Gen Khin Nyunt. The feared spy chief and former premier was eliminated, together with his entire intelligence structure, in a 2004 purge, and Than Shwe erased one of his potential rivals.

Shwe Mann was one of several young officers elevated by Than Shwe over the years to top positions in the armed forces and the cabinet. Others included  Gen Thein Sein, Lt-Gen Myint Swe, head of the Bureau of Special Operations (5), and Minister of Agriculture and Irrigation Maj-Gen Htay Oo, who is now head of the Union Solidarity Development Association.

Sources suggest that although Shwe Mann is considered to be down-to-earth he hasn’t gained as much of Than Shwe's trust and confidence as he needs.  Htay Oo and Myint Swe have become Than Shwe’s favorites following the loss of  his trusted general, former Prime Minister Soe Win, who died in 2007.

It will be hardly surprising if Than Shwe chooses to cling to power after the election, considering the financial benefits and security of office. The members of Burma's junta have deep pockets, fat foreign currency bank accounts and lucrative business interests that would assure them of a comfortable existence for years to come.
 
But how can he remain in power as president?

The military will receive 25 percent of the seats at the village, township, state, regional and district levels in the new governing body, according to the 2008 Constitution. There will be three nominees for the presidency—one from the Amyotha Hluttaw (Nationalities Parliament or Senate), one from the members of the Pyithu Hluttaw (People's Assembly or House) and one from the military contingent of the two Hluttaws. The Senate and the House will then vote to choose the president.

Than Shwe can be nominated by the representatives of the military in the future Senate and House, to be formed after the planned 2010 election.

According to the Constitution, one of the duties of the new president will be to head the National Defense and Security Council, which will have the power to declare a state of emergency and nullify the Constitution.

Than Shwe currently holds Burma’s most powerful position in the armed forces and analysts say he will hand this position over only to his most trusted ally. Myint Swe, who is in his mid 50s, could assume this position.

Shwe Mann now oversees regular meetings on political and security affairs with high-ranking military officials in Rangoon and Mandalay, although Than Shwe still calls the shots.

The question now is who will be commander in chief of the armed forces?
Myint Swe, a protégé of Than Shwe and close associate of the general and his wife, is a prime candidate for the job.

One interesting theory is that after claiming to build modern and strong armed forces, Than Shwe will be reluctant to let a strong army leader now take over.



1  |  2 



COMMENTS (10)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

Moe Aung Wrote:
28/03/2010
plan B:

Tell us something we don't already know - not TS calling the shots whatever, or the polls not happening if it's not going according to plan. It's all in the hands of the puppet master naturally.

Funny you should mention intimidation. It's TS who's doing all the intimidation, and as you rightly point out, the Burmese hate that more than anything. They'll have their vengeance and TS his comeuppance. Has he any insight as to his best exit strategy? Nope.

plan B Wrote:
27/03/2010
Ko Moe Aung,

Let me simplify for you and your ilk:
1)Than Shwe will still call the shots before or after this sham election under any pretext.

2)This Sham election can still "NOT HAPPEN".

3)Why has not the west inject anything in this present dynamic knowing the result The Irrawaddy is clearly highlighting?

4) Than Shwe can be bought but not intimidated.

You should know the last one well as Burmese especially the intimidation part.

Moe Aung Wrote:
26/03/2010
plan B

"after all the useless careless western failed policy and still the west has done NOTHING to change the inevitable"

It's all down to the West, isn't it? 'Nothing to do with me, Guv' says the junta. And the people? They don't figure, except as hapless aid receivers in your scheme of things, do they? Just parroting on and on and on, aren't you? Can't even recycle it properly to help your cause. Two out of ten, again.

"So why should Snr-Gen Than Shwe not continue as he has had and had it so well?"

His reforming zeal got the better of him? Suddenly woken up after his entire selfish life flashed past in a nightmarish dream? His astrologer read him the riot act - he must relent or else?

The need for an exit strategy, my dear Watson, as you well know. Hope his demise is anything but peaceful.

Moe Aung Wrote:
26/03/2010
plan B,

Sorry, it's not helping when your rants get more and more incoherent and convoluted with a lot of careless mistakes. Could do better. Two out of ten. Make some effort and don't rush.

plan B Wrote:
26/03/2010
"It's no joking matter—Than Shwe will indeed probably consider this proposal and give it his nod."
Ko Aung Zaw is absolutely right on.
So the fact remains, SPDC proceeding with the SOS that it started out with 20 years ago after all the useless careless western failed policy and still the west has done NOTHING to change the inevitable.
Talk to anyone in the street of Yangon or elsewhere on the coming sham election. They still do not believe it will yet happen. Even if it shall come to past, they do not see any much change economically with only the same piece of pie shared among the junta and its cronies.
So why should SGTS not continue as he has had and had it so well?
Power, greed and assurance of a peaceful demise.

plan B Wrote:
25/03/2010
Any one with 1/2 a brain will realize that SGTS will have a role to play in the future of Myanmar even under the ideal circumstances in all aspects.
So why:
1) Is the west led by US still insisting on the old rules of HR 2330?
2) Why are no direct honest negotiation on behalf of the citizenry well-being being done instead of "you can jump high enough no matter how high you jump" of the past?

[The rest of this post was deleted due to use of abbreviations for which no definition was supplied. eg c/w Ed]

Kyaik-ka-san Wrote:
20/03/2010
Than Shwe’s concern has been incremental. As he committed too many crimes, poor old man’s final days are passing like hell. The hurdles he came across day by day made him almost suffocated.

Before he is able to decide “self-appointed” or “protégé-protection” option, latest development keeps him awake at night gain. The new subject he has to learn this time is “War-Crime”.

He should first analyze impact of the subject on the election law. He pressed prisoners of conscience are not eligible. Then, what about SPDC and generals that committed killing, rapping and torturing? Also, how Kyant Phut members are going to register in the election, because they are authentic “state-terrorist”.

UN proposed to brand SPDC and generals as War Crimes. EU, Japan, Asean, US and others follow Australia to support the proposal sooner or later. When ICC confirms this, what so-called trusted officer will do? They will send TS and others to Hague or be included in the list.

What will they choose?

George Than Setkyar Heine Wrote:
20/03/2010
Yes, Than Shwe could be in dilemma over choosing a lackey who would guarantee him and his family in the post 2010 election era no doubt.

In case he feels comfortable he could hand over the post to Shwe Mann, which would be more than relevant and reasonable at this time given his seniority, experience and stand in the hierarchy as well.

If this is not the case Than Shwe stands to earn more enmity and anger among his rank and file.

Of course Myint Swe and younger generals would not like to give up their uniforms and power at the moment also.

It is best for Than Shwe to move the older generals and civilians to administrative posts for a start and set a precedent and procedure for the future as well.

However, Gen. Tin Aung Myint Oo is not mentioned here for that matter.

I know this guy has more clout and credibility than most in the lot.

He is totally DISENCHANTED or DISGUSTED and has opted for retirement.

Maybe he knows the game is up and has chosen his path I am sure.

Moe Aung Wrote:
20/03/2010
I reckon it's not just Than Shwe's dilemma but his subordinate generals' too over which role to hang on to - having troops under their command or high office in government,and the most coveted position could well be Minister of Defense cum Chief of Staff.After all they know only too well that power comes from the barrel of a gun;they have themselves proved it again and again.Khin Nyunt's demise was a case in point;control of military intelligence is a poor substitute for control of armed men,battle-trained and ready for combat.

People's Power movement in a country like Burma should take these lessons on board,and vigorously seek control of armed troops,in this case the Tatmadaw rank and file to be won over by political agitation.In a recurrent worst case scenario of yet another brutal crackdown,only this strategy can help level the playing field and move toward a likely reversal of fortunes.Will the NLD rise up to the challenge?It's boxed into a corner as we speak.It's do or die now.

A.M.O Wrote:
20/03/2010
Well, what goes up must come down, no matter what.

And naturally a time will come when Than Shwe can't go up any further but to come down only.

Since Than Shwe is a staunch Buddhist, he might as well believe "Karma or Kan";and the more you believe in it, the more one is afraid of doing evils - to kill, to steal etc.

But Than Shwe keep on doing these evils as if he doesn't believe in it.

Now in his late 70s, he contemplates, in the world of junta generals' dog-eat-dog culture, how to get a gracious transit.

And the memory of Gen Ne Win's downfall & ungracious end (under Than Shwe's house-arrest)might be haunting him endlessly.

So,we see how gracious his transit will be as fated by 'Karma'.


More Articles in This Section

bullet Sizing Up an Icon

bullet Fighting Corruption Begins at Home

bullet Future of Exiled Burmese Media

bullet How Much Freedom Does Burmese Media Enjoy?

bullet Five Days in Burma

bullet Turning Burma into Next Asian Tiger No Simple Task

bullet With Suu Kyi On Board, Is Burma Finally Moving Toward Real Change?

bullet The ‘Rule of Law’ in Burma

bullet New Doors are Opening in Burma

bullet A Good Beginning to the New Year






Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

Donations

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.