A Grim Trade: Trafficking Palaung Women to China
covering burma and southeast asia
Saturday, April 20, 2024
Burma

A Grim Trade: Trafficking Palaung Women to China


By SIMON ROUGHNEEN Tuesday, June 14, 2011


Many Burmese women trafficked were forced to marry Chinese men and were coerced into the sex trade. (Photo: Katsuo Takahashi)
COMMENTS (8)
RECOMMEND (335)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
PLUSONE
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

BANGKOK—Unscrupulous traffickers, Burma's economic decline and militarization, and a shortage of females caused by China's “One Child Policy” have all combined to contribute to the trafficking of women from the Palaung region of Burma into China, says a locally based activist group.

“Since 2007, we have documented 72 cases of actual and suspected trafficking involving 110 people,” said Lway Moe Kam of the Palaung Women's Organisation (PWO). The caseload includes 11 children under 10 years of age.

Twenty-five percent of the women trafficked were forced to marry Chinese men and 10 percent of the caseload were coerced into the sex trade, according to the PWO, which grimly concluded that nine out of 10 trafficking victims do not escape.

According to a particularly gruesome account given by one victim of trafficking, she was taken to a building in Shandong, eastern China, where people were kept as live feed for leeches, used in Chinese medicine. “I saw some people in that room lying in pools of water. They were all fat, but looked lifeless and were not moving. Then I saw that there were leeches sucking those people's blood,” said the unnamed woman.

The PWO concedes that the number of trafficking victims is likely to be higher than reported, with real figures difficult to determine due to local cultural constraints, further hampered by the logistical and security challenges confronting researchers working in the area. In 60 percent of the cases analysed, it remained unclear exactly what kind of situation the victim was trafficked into.

“Traffickers work in secret, and the presence of the army means that we have to be careful when doing research and talking to people,” said Lway Aye Nang, another PWO representative.

Palaung culture frowns upon extramarital sex, meaning that trafficked women who suffer sexual crimes “are often reluctant to admit they have been trafficked,” said Lway Moe Kah, the lead author of the PWO report, “Stolen Lives—Human Trafficking from Palaung Areas of Burma into China.”

In perhaps a surprising finding, 65 percent of the trafficking perpetrators were female, a factor that Lway Moe Kam puts down to the greater trust placed in women by the eventual victim of trafficking. "It sounds better if the job offer is made by a woman," she said, though Khin Ohmar, a Burmese exile activist based in Chiang Mai, cautioned that the female perpetrators might themselves be coerced into recruitment by other traffickers, likely male, who dominate the trade.

The investigation focused on the townships of Namkahn, Namhsan and Mantong in the Palaung region of Shan State, which sits on the Burma-China frontier. In the absence of recent census date, the Palaung are thought to number around one million people, mostly mountain-dwellers in an area laden with gold, silver, zinc and aluminum.

China's one Child Policy has contributed to a relative scarcity of women in the country, with the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences recently predicting that 24 million Chinese men of marrying age could be unable to find a wife by 2020. While the laws are not as aggressively imposed in rural areas close to Burma as they are in China's eastern seaboard cities, they contribute to a growing gender imbalance, with sex selection abortions “extremely common,” according to the Academy.

With families restricted by law to one, or perhaps two children, a cultural preference for male offspring has been exacerbated, said the Chinese researchers, resulting in 119 boys born for every 100 girls, a disparity that rises to 130-100 in some rural areas.

According to US government in its 2010 report on global human trafficking trends, Burma's government has been working to combat some aspects of trafficking, such as the international sex trade. Burma prohibits sex and labor trafficking through its 2005 Anti-Trafficking in Persons Law, in which traffickers are classed in the same category as rapists.



1  |  2  next page »

COMMENTS (8)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

chris Jericho Wrote:
24/06/2011
Which parts of comments say that Burmese dissident should stop promoting human rights? I'm all for human rights and racial equality. Is twisting others' words your way of expressing opinions?

Do you even understand how to express your opinions without having to resort to racism?

tocharian Wrote:
23/06/2011
If human traffickers, smugglers and drug-dealers (and don't tell Chinese are not involved!) are the ones bringing "progress and prosperity" to Burma, then so be it. A prostitute deserves the pimps she has. A country deserves what it tolerates. Let the corrupt pimps of Burma prosper and with the same "logic", that Jericho wants me to apply, Burmese dissidents should stop talking about human rights etc., if it's only a pure façade for the Western media that is used to cover up other clandestine operations.

Heroes are brave, honest and intelligent. Saw Lu didn't deserve Kyansittha.

Sai Wrote:
21/06/2011
tocharian, u should take a beer box and make some speech in Bogyoke Zay in Rangoon, like Hitler did in 20s. That will make you feel better. I will be one of your audience though.

chris Jericho Wrote:
21/06/2011
Well, on the other side, those foreigners provide much-needed employment to locals who are not fortunate enough to leave for greener pastures like you did. A country of 50-million people can't live on hand-outs from UNHCR and UNDP forever, especially while being ruled by the uncaring government. At the same time, those very foreigners serve as clandestine channels between the dissidents inside the country and the outside world because the junta dare not cut off their own life line. Not only the colonial masters you so cherish but also the Koreans, Singaporeans, Thai, and yes, both Chinese and Taiwanese are the part of the equation that helps bring about changes to Burma.

@ Tocharian - what surprises me is that you live in the most liberal country in both Americas but your mindset is so closeted.

tocharian Wrote:
19/06/2011
Oh I didn't know that NLD is also mainly funded by the Chinese, just like the rest of Burma!

As chris jericho said, I will have to apply more "logic" to what's happening in Burma and I conclude that it's worse than I ever imagined, especially with all those "ultra-competitive cut-throat Chinese" from Hongkong and Singapore (not just the simple Yunnanese illegal immigrants in Myitkyina)
By the way, I am not a religious person so I don't meditate and I certainly don't pray to Chinese Gods like rannine!

rannine Wrote:
16/06/2011
I agree with chris. We have to thank the Chinese. All that we are using today is made by Chinese.

Chinese are our paukphaws, gurus, thakhingyees. I pray to Chinese everyday.

Why don't we pay to the Burmese girls also?

chris jericho Wrote:
16/06/2011
@ tocharian - can't pass one day without insulting chinese, can you? there are laws to deal with human traffickers in every country. if they are caught, they will be executed for sure. insulting the whole ethnic group for the sins of a fraction of it is quite pathetic to begin with. if i have to apply your logic to things happening in burma, the ruling class of burma is all burmese, you know. if you read articles in this website clearly, you will find that the first nation that congratulated NLD for its 1990 election victory was china, one year after 1989 tiananmen incident. one would think their conscince would keep themselves away from NLD. and even till now, NLD receives majority of its financial support from ethnic chinese merchants inside burma, for god sake. I'm sorry for you if you had been out-competed at work by chinese. I know those canadian-chinese from hong kong can be ultra-competitive. take deep breath and let it go. or meditate like a true buddhist.

tocharian Wrote:
15/06/2011
This is a sad story but I've been warning everyone about the effect of this Chinese Y-chromosome surplus problem for some time. People didn't really understand me at first (but that also happened to Cassandra).
This is just the tip of the iceberg. China really thinks of Burma as their Wild West Frontier where they can come in and take whatever they need (and leave the rubbish for the Burmese as the recent article in The Economist was saying). The NLD should address these issues and perhaps this is a good strategy to unite Burma against a common enemy: the aggressive Chinese. Look how the Vietnamese are reacting violently to the Chinese claim of some islands far out in the sea. In Burma, it's not even about some disputed territory. China basically views all of Burma as their colony nowadays, good for Gas, Gems, Girls and other things

more articles in this section