The Irrawaddy News Magazine [Covering Burma and Southeast Asia]
COVER STORY
Than Shwe—Man in the Iron Mask
By AUNG ZAW FEBRUARY, 2005 - VOLUME 13 NO.2

Burma’s paramount leader may be an unknown figure to most, but he has shown his leadership mettle

 

The Burmese hardly know their paramount leader, Snr-Gen Than Shwe. His former close friends knew him as an honest and simple soldier. But even if he lacks charisma and possesses few rounded leadership skills today, he has an iron grip on power.

 

 

Lately there has been a proliferation of tales and rumors about him and his family, though reliable sources have trouble verifying them. The reclusive Than Shwe rarely meets journalists, and the government releases only snippets of news about his and his family’s activities.

 

Rumor has it that Than Shwe acts like a king, and his daughters order military officers to treat them like royalty. Some insiders say he wants to be remembered as a benevolent king. The 72-year-old general is known to bear a grudge against the regime’s main opponent Aung San Suu Kyi, who has been under house arrest on and off since 1989. Just the mention of her name is said to send him into tantrums.

 

Domestically, Than Shwe is said to like watching Chinese Shaolin martial art movies, and his favorite grandsons are treated like contenders. He occasionally plays golf, a pastime favored by military brass, including his late predecessor Ne Win.

 

But there are some hard facts breaking through the wall of silence around Burma’s paramount leader. Born in 1933 in Kyaukse, Mandalay Division, Than Shwe joined the army aged 20. Before that he was a lowly postal clerk. A year later, he attended the Officer Training School as an Intake 9 student and became an army officer before enrolling in the civilian Institute of Central Politics. In 1958 he was attached to the army’s psychological warfare department.

 

CHURNING OUT THAN SHWE’S PORTRAITS: Cult in the making?
His rapid rise in the army began with postings in Karen and Shan states. But little has been recorded about any battles with minority ethnic insurgents there. In 1978, at the age of 50, he reached the rank of colonel and was one of the youngest commanders in the army in the military’s Southwest Region. Ten years later he was a lieutenant-general.

 

He was a member of Ne Win’s ruling Burma Socialist Program Party, or BSPP, where he became a central executive committee member in 1988. Analysts note his political thinking today is still very much in the style of the old BSPP. For instance he set up a BSPP-style Union Solidarity Development Association, of which he became chairman. He also convened a National Convention in 1993, ostensibly to draft a constitution. But the convention has yet to achieve anything.

 

During the long BSPP era, Than Shwe was known as a faithful anti-reformist. But while the party only nominally embraced socialism, he is known to be a strong believer in the ideology.

 

In 1985, Than Shwe became deputy commander-in-chief of the army and deputy defense minister. Three years later he became deputy chairman of the ruling State Law and Order Restoration Council, or SLORC, which replaced the BSPP. Then in 1992 he became chairman of the new ruling State Peace and Development Council, or SPDC.

 

There is no record of his ever traveling to a western country. Now, he would not be allowed to go even if he wanted to. Than Shwe and other high ranking officials in the regime face visa bans imposed by western countries.

 

After his appointment as leader, Than Shwe held a series of secret cabinet meetings. They were known as nya kyaung, or night school, because they took place at night. Than Shwe, of course, was “headmaster.” At these meetings, the general reportedly made careful and calculated policy decisions about the course of the country and the armed forces. Some generals who attend the nya kyaung now hold senior jobs with the junta. For instance, Lt-Gen Thein Sein, now SPDC’s Secretary One, and Lt-Gen Khin Maung Than, a senior SPDC member and a leading official in the Defense Ministry, were among those who regularly showed up at Than Shwe’s night school in the early 1990s.

 

He is married to an ethnic Pa-O, Daw Kyaing Kyaing. Many friends who knew them in the 1980s recall that Than Shwe’s family were unusually modest at the time. Like many other superstitious generals— particularly Ne Win—and their families, Than Shwe and his wife are known to seek advice from astrologers and monks. Unlike Ne Win’s family, Than Shwe’s sons and daughters have not been actively involved in big business.

 

However, Than Shwe’s son, Kyaing San Shwe, and his wife are known to dabble in business. They run the Classic International Company, involved in construction and making iron grills. The son is also thought to be involved in the illegal gambling business.

 

The Than Shwe family is also well connected with a young Burmese tycoon, Te Za (sometimes written Teza). The businessman, 40, is President and Managing Director of Htoo Trading Company, a major player in Burma’s tourism, logging, real estate and hotel and housing development industries.

 

Since 1993, he has also been involved in the arms industry. His Myanmar Avia Export is the country’s sole representative of Russia’s Export Military Industrial Group, which makes aircraft parts, and helicopter-maker Rostvertol. He was instrumental in helping the junta buy MiG-29 fighters and helicopters from Russia.

 

Than Shwe’s eldest daughter is also the talk of the town as Te Za’s apparent girlfriend. And Te Za is supposed to have arranged Singapore shopping trips for the general’s wife, Daw Kyaing Kyaing.

 

Than Shwe and his wife Daw Kyaing Kyaing pose in front of a Buddhist shrine near Patna, during a visit to India in October 2004

Although one of Than Shwe’s main reasons for removing Khin Nyunt was his alleged corruption, he has turned a blind eye to close allies considered unusually wealthy. Three such friends, Lt-Gen Maung Bo, Lt-Gen Ye Myint and Industry Minister Aung Thaung are, according to western diplomats, notoriously corrupt, and unusually wealthy despite their relatively modest army salaries. But Than Shwe has ignored the reports, perhaps considering personal loyalty more important.

 

Than Shwe was also agriculture minister under SLORC, and this is where he developed a fascination for building dams. In Kyaukse, his birthplace, he has built schools, hospitals, factories, a university and an international airport.

 

The general is untutored in international affairs, and his understanding of diplomacy has been questionable. But so far he has managed to keep good relations with neighboring countries. He officially sticks to a “neutral” foreign policy, but under his rule Burma is regarded as becoming more of a stooge of China. The neighboring power has remained one of the few countries supplying the junta with arms, diplomatic support and aid.

 

Than Shwe also plays the India card. The junta now receives loans from both rival neighboring powers. New Delhi initially supported Suu Kyi and the Burmese democracy movement for some years. But it has now noticeably toned this down. Insiders say Than Shwe plays China and India off against each other to secure loans and assistance, including for his birthplace Kyaukse.

 

For trade and strategic reasons, the two giants have an interest in keeping Burma’s military leadership intact. But China clearly wants to retain its Big Brother status with Burma.

 

A few days after he sacked prime minister and military intelligence chief Gen Khin Nyunt last October, Than Shwe went to India. New Delhi rolled out the red carpet for him. While India undoubtedly wants to keep Burma out of China’s orbit, the Chinese are stepping up their efforts to gain access to the Bay of Bengal and the Andaman Sea via Burma.

 

Analysts noted Beijing was concerned about the removal of Khin Nyunt, widely seen as pro-China. At the same time, Than Shwe has no wish to upset the Chinese leadership, Burma’s main ally and benefactor. Gen Shwe Mann, a leading junta figure, was dispatched on an unannounced visit to Beijing the following month. Prime Minister Soe Win also made several trips to China during the year.

 

Than Shwe’s last visit to Beijing was in 2003. He secured new loans and generally bolstered bilateral relations. After his trip, his stance toward Suu Kyi noticeably hardened, analysts noted. During the recent tsunami crisis, which also affected Burma, Rangoon turned down bilateral aid from foreign governments but accepted it from China.

 

As a member of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, or Asean, Than Shwe is likely to try to maintain friendly relations with neighboring Thailand and other countries in the region. Importantly, in 2006 Burma is going to take over Asean’s rotating chairmanship. It will therefore host numerous Asean official meetings. There has been pressure both from within and outside Asean to hold these meetings in other member countries if the junta still refuses to move towards political reform.

 

Yet analysts believe Rangoon is in no hurry to bow to external pressure to move toward reforms. Some analysts even question whether Burma still wants to be a member of Asean. In or out of the regional grouping, Rangoon can generally expect little trouble from its neighbors, while relations with the United States and other western countries will remain rocky.

 

Apart from its economic and political sanctions against the regime, the US can be expected to remain the biggest vocal critic of the regime. Only last month, Condoleezza Rice made a statement during her Senate confirmation hearing naming Burma as an “outpost of tyranny.” In her statement, Rice lumped Burma in with other countries it considers pariah states: North Korea, Iran, Cuba, Belarus and Zimbabwe.

 

Observers feel the new label will make Than Shwe a bit anxious—not that he will lose any sleep over it. He should be aware that Burma is not at the top of the US global hit-list. And he can point to the ongoing National Convention, supposed to be drawing up a new constitution, and even free Suu Kyi if pressure mounts significantly.

 

While the country is in a state of political and economic despair, Than Shwe has been quietly consolidating personal power, despite earlier reports that he was ill and about to retire. All things considered, the former postal clerk has done quite well. He is not regarded as cold-blooded, but he has taken calculated risks to pre-empt trouble—and if he perceives any threat from within the Tatmadaw, or armed forces, he has shown he can be ruthless.

 

He deals with any hint of trouble in the Tatmadaw in much the same way as Ne Win before him. Ne Win would remove anyone he believed to be disobedient, disloyal or becoming popular enough to be a potential rival. Than Shwe has followed exactly the same path. In this, he has exercised a famous Burmese saying: kyu-bin-koke-kyu-ngok-ma-kyan-zeya. That means if you remove reeds you should take out everything, not even leaving stumps that could sprout again. Thus when Khin Nyunt was purged, many of his associates went with him, and even those with links to the general face an uncertain fate.

 

Under Than Shwe, the Tatmadaw is no longer accountable to the people and the nation. The armed forces are not protecting or serving the people, but simply propping up a group of warlords while clinging to power themselves. Burmese society is still feudal, with no rules for succession.

 

Than Shwe may have overstayed his welcome at the top. But there are no signs he is about to give up his throne.

 

Uncertainty in Rangoon

 

Even high-ranking officers are not sure where they stand

 

By Aung Zaw

 

Last month, rumors in Rangoon indicated a bitter quarrel had broken out among the regime’s three top leaders and that the generals had a bizarre gun battle, resulting in the death of a bodyguard. A major military reshuffle was expected, and some senior high ranking officials, including the prime minister, were about to be axed, so the rumors went.

 

Some observers think the gun battle story was sparked by the death “on duty” of Lt-Col Bo Win Tun, 42, Dep Snr-Gen Maung Aye’s personal assistant. Many believe he was killed in the cowboy-style shoot out. There was no official explanation of how he died.

 

 

The rumor mills were further fed by the mysterious public disappearance for weeks of newly appointed Prime Minister Lt-Gen Soe Win. It prompted Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra to say that political tension in Burma was rising.

 

As anticipated, all top brass subsequently appeared in public in an obvious show of unity. But many remained unconvinced that all was well.

 

Since the removal of former military intelligence chief and prime minister Gen Khin Nyunt in October last year, the regime’s stability and unity have been continually questioned. Military watchers say the effects of the purge are still being felt in Rangoon, and within the armed forces.

 

High ranking officials in Khin Nyunt’s now-disbanded military intelligence network have also been put on trial behind prison walls in Rangoon. Their testimony could well put many other officials in danger.

 

“There is a tremendous amount of uncertainty,” said one veteran journalist based in the capital. He lamented: “Even high ranking officers are not sure where they stand at the moment— if they are found to be linked to Khin Nyunt, they will be fired and face trial.”

 

Some local observers said the generals may have disagreed about the National Convention on drawing up a new constitution, which reconvened in late February, and how to deal with ethnic minority groups. Some army leaders wanted powerful Wa and other ethnic groups to be disarmed.

 

The generals may be quarreling, but this time the main struggle is believed to be between Army Commander Dep Snr-Gen Maung Aye and his junta boss Snr-Gen Than Shwe.

 

Maung Aye was supposed to take over the helm from Than Shwe several years ago. But he remains deputy chairman of the ruling State Peace and Development Council, or SPDC.

 

Oddly enough, Maung Aye was only recently given the newly-created rank of deputy senior general, suggesting that Than Shwe was not ready to leave.

 

Than Shwe is also thought to be grooming Gen Thura Shwe Mann to head the armed forces. Military watchers say Shwe Mann, who is known to be an assertive number three in the ruling junta, is being groomed to take over from Than Shwe. The junta leader still holds the most powerful military position of Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces. But it is unclear whether Maung Aye or Shwe Mann will be given this top position.

 

Observers say Maung Aye is the “John Wayne of Burma.” He is known as a quick-thinking combat commander. Unlike Maung Aye, Than Shwe is more like a chess player and schemer, thus making Maung Aye stand out like a sore thumb and maybe likely to be axed.

 

Many observers are also doubtful that Maung Aye, 65, will be given the number one position. Since 2000, there has been strong speculation within SPDC circles that if Than Shwe retired he will bring down Maung Aye with him.

 

Maung Aye, who was from Defense Services Academy (Batch 1), seems to have lost much of his clout, some critics believe. But those in Maung Aye’s camp are thought to have said that Than Shwe has lost the plot. They think Maung Aye seems to have his own vision.

 

Maung Aye (some former friends says he is half-Chinese) was believed to have been behind Khin Nyunt’s downfall. The two were at loggerheads for many years. But this does not necessarily mean Maung Aye’s star is rising.

 

If Than Shwe thinks Maung Aye is becoming a threat to his throne, he won’t be spared. But it could be premature to regard Maung Aye as a threat. Military observers say Than Shwe does not brook any hint of a threat, and would use a charge of high treason against his rivals.

 

Than Shwe didn’t even tolerate his own former boss, Ne Win, who spent his last days under house arrest. Ne Win’s grandsons are under detention charged with high treason, and his favorite daughter, Sandar Win, is still under house arrest.

 

Some analysts say Maung Aye is smart enough to figure out what’s going on. One western businessman with a keen interest in Burma, commenting on the tension, said:  “This is an unsustainable situation. It won’t work.” He added: “My opinion is the fight will continue. But Than Shwe has all the cards and he can push a button to remove his rivals anytime he wants.”

 

Cynically, the businessman said that in this dog-eat-dog business “the one who pulls the gun the fastest will be the winner.”

Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group | www.irrawaddy.org