ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION | VIDEO





COMMENTARY
Strengthening Kyat Gets the Experts Thinking
By YENI Tuesday, December 1, 2009


COMMENTS (11)
RECOMMEND (521)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

The recent rise in the value of the Burmese kyat against the US dollar is giving not only currency traders cause for thought. Financial experts and market observers are also looking into the likely reason for the newly won strength of the kyat, which has appreciated from around 1,200 kyat to the dollar in mid-November to the current rate of 990 kyat.

Since 2005, when a dollar cost just 880 kyat, the Burmese currency steadily declined in value, hitting a three-year low of 1,190 kyat to the dollar in January this year. Since then, however, the downwards trend has reversed, and today the currency trades on the black market at around 995 kyat to the dollar.

Traditionally, one of the most important factors that influence the exchange rate of the kyat is the constant change in restrictions on imports and exports. When the restrictions are tight on imports, there is less demand for US dollars in the market, and the value of the kyat rises. When the import restrictions are relaxed, demand for the US dollar rises and the value of the kyat falls. But this factor has not influenced the current strength of the kyat, currency dealers say. 

Although Burma has no official currency market, the US dollar is always subject to intense speculation. Some big-time speculators purchase tens of thousands of US dollars in order to push up the value of the greenback, tricking other investors into buying large amounts of the US currency. In the volatile market conditions that follow, the speculators resell their dollars at a handsome profit.

In Burma, the US dollar holds sway in the street markets, although the Thai baht and Chinese yuan are also often accepted, particularly in border trade,  while such convertible currencies as the Euro, the Japanese yen and Australian dollar are shunned.

Large amounts of dollars change hands daily at Rangoon's Bogyoke Aung San market, which has several currency exchanges, none of them authorized.

The market's currency dealers, who set the black market rate for the US dollar, agree that the worldwide depreciation in the value of the greenback could be a reason for the kyat's sudden strength.

Dealers say a rise in the number of tourists visiting Burma is also contributing to the rise in the value of the kyat. An official with Myanmar [Burma] Travels and Tours, run by Burma's Ministry of Hotels and Tourism, has announced that tourist numbers are up by at least 30 percent on last year. The 260,000-plus tourists who visited the country during the past year contributed US $165 million to state coffers.

Another factor contributing to the strength of the kyat, according to currency dealers, is the contribution in earnings from the trade in opium and amphetamines at the Sino-Burmese border.

The rise in the kyat coincided with the start of the cold season, when most opium farmers harvest their crops.  A currency dealer in Rangoon said: “The rate this time is not determined by the circumstances in Rangoon markets. The exchange rate of the Chinese currency versus the kyat at the border has affected Rangoon.”

This theory finds support in a report by the UN Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC). Releasing the report, “2009 Patterns and Trends of Amphetamine-Type Stimulants and Other Drugs in East and South-East Asia,”  UNODC representative Gary Lewis told the reporters in Bangkok that Burma's armed ethnic groups—particularly in the Shan, Wa and Kokang areas—are increasingly cashing in their stocks of illegal drugs in expectation of a junta crackdown. The regime has in recent months stepped up its pressure on the ethnic groups ahead of the elections planned for 2010.

If this theory stands, the main reasons for the kyat's appreciation seem to be coming from events outside Naypyidaw’s control and are no indicator of the strength of the Burmese economy.

But who knows? Like the US, Britain or any of the countries of the G8 that printed money to get out of recession, Burma's ruling generals, who aren't known for their skill in managing the country's economy, might be tempted to create more kyat banknotes. Currency chaos could be the result.



COMMENTS (11)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

TeethLa Wrote:
10/12/2009
Car auctions in Naypyidaw sound very elegant.
But the real thing that car brokers are paying for is the vin number imprinted on the metal frame.

Sounds crazy? You bet! That vin number will cost a minimum of $4,000 depending on the model. I am not going into detail but you should get an idea about the profits that will go to the government and car brokers.

I suggest that Ko Tura should clarify this.

BBC Wrote:
09/12/2009
First-class people left the country, and third- class people (the junta) are leading the country while second-class (with some first-class people) are living in low-profile...

Myanmar Patriot 4 UMPF Wrote:
06/12/2009
Thura Zaw Hein:"Rumours are in circulation that junta does not want Kyats to stay in the hands of the public before the election. Biggest vote buying power will win the game."

If this is the case, the junta-backed party will win hands down,with billions of kyats siphoned off sales proceeds from gas, etc. Does it also imply that democracy is nothing but a corrupt game of bribery, where money brainwashes gullible people? In Chicago, Obama's stronghold, the saying is that he who has gold wins the elections. So democracy is not really what it is cracked up to be.

United Myanmar Patriot Front
(Myanmar Myotchit Asheh Pwefh)

Thura Zaw Hein Wrote:
04/12/2009
US Dollar starts to depreciate by October until end of Chinese new year and Burmese water festival. It starts to appreciate by end of April. The lowest time is normally in December/January and the highest time is around August/September. It goes in cycle year by year.

Increased taxation and recent property and car auctions show the sign of retracting Kyats from the public and stoppage of multi-million kyat projects shows the sign of preventing outflow of Kyats. Rumours are in circulation that junta does not want Kyats to stay in the hands of the public before the election. Biggest vote buying power will win the game.

TeethLa Wrote:
03/12/2009
No doubt that the kyat normally strengthens during the drug-booming season, like Yeni said. There is no way officially to measure the actual value of the kyat since the exchange rate is unofficial and therefore the value of the kyat depends on the demand for dollars used in illegal border trading.

It is a joke that the cost of license plates is more expensive than the value of a vehicle in Burma for decades. Currently, a bowl of steamed rice costs 500 kyat, a cup of mocca costs above 2500 kyat (appearance equivalent to Starbucks but not the taste), a roast duck costs 15,000 kyat and are mostly enjoyed by rich people.

A new bank note of 5000 kyat can be rarely seen and used in the market. Rumors say that it will be withdrawn anytime or the currency will be revalued. Vietnam had done it recently. North Korea is on process. Is Burma next?

plan B Wrote:
03/12/2009
Yeni,
Good news that your exposés are critically read. Therefore, you need to be more reasonable.
Are the good old days of throwing any unrelated facts in to blame the SPDC gone for good?
The Burmese hoard gold in good times sell it during bad. This is a bad time and people are selling their gold to make ends meet, especially with recent circulation of 5,000 kyat notes that contribute to inflation.

As for the true reason for devaluation of the dollar in Myanmar, Yeni should tell us:
Have the likes of Tay Za being buying up gold to hedge against inflation lately?
Then Yeni will have to admit how dire the Myanmar economy is from the evidence of dependence on cronies with dollars that make a difference, albeit in a very twisted way.

Myanmar Patriot 4 UMPF Wrote:
02/12/2009
It is so very simple. Too many dollars are being printed. Nothing to do with what is happening in Burma. Sterling is also deteriorating, too. Nothing to do with the baht and the yuan. Just refer to the quantity theory and parity theory. Or you can contact us: [email protected]. MINGLABAR

Thura Wrote:
02/12/2009
A very good question from alayman. It is unfair to say that drug money is the main reason. You should not forget to mention the income from natural gas, which may be one of the main reasons together with global USD depreciation against other currencies.

Given a strengthening trend of Burmese kyat over the past few years, people in Burma no longer rush to buy USD to protect themselves from inflation as they did in the past. This sentimental factor also helps the kyat to appreciate against the USD.

KKK Wrote:
02/12/2009
This is a great analysis. Thanks to Yeni.
If the Burmese currency is really strengthening, why don't the commodities price go down? What about the kyat against the Thai baht? What about the kyat against Chinese yuan? Why don't the Chinese yuan and Thai baht values go down like the US dollar? Look at the US dollar against the Chinese yuan and Thai baht. The US dollar value does not go down a lot. I would like to hear some comments from Dr. Tin Soe, Dr. Sein Htay, Dr. Maw Than, Dr. Than Nyunt, and U Maung Maung Nyo on the current strengthening kyat. If the experts from Naypyidaw know how to control the currency market, Obama should get advice from these experts to fight against the Chinese yuan.

alayman Wrote:
01/12/2009
hi YENI,

As I asked before, is this the only year drug-dollars are coming into the local market? How about the last 15 years?

timothy Wrote:
01/12/2009
Than Shwe does not care about currency strength and will not give a thought about it at all. He simply does not understand it. The most likely reason is dollars pumping into country from illicit drugs and sale of gas/oil by the junta. War is looming in border regions and Than Shwe will use biological weapons to annihilate the ethnic brothers to the pleasure of China and the UN. Asean will give wild applause, believe me.

More Articles in This Section

bullet Sizing Up an Icon

bullet Fighting Corruption Begins at Home

bullet Future of Exiled Burmese Media

bullet How Much Freedom Does Burmese Media Enjoy?

bullet Five Days in Burma

bullet Turning Burma into Next Asian Tiger No Simple Task

bullet With Suu Kyi On Board, Is Burma Finally Moving Toward Real Change?

bullet The ‘Rule of Law’ in Burma

bullet New Doors are Opening in Burma

bullet A Good Beginning to the New Year






Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

Donations

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.